Milburn review urges 'radical' welfare reforms to tackle youth unemployment

Nearly half a million young people could be helped into work by 2036, the Milburn report says, but it warns reforms will "not be pain-free".

Fewer benefits for young people, a promise of guaranteed paid jobs, and a timeline to reduce employers’ hiring costs.

These are three of the recommendations for welfare and employment reform made by Alan Milburn, who published a report on Tuesday on how the UK can best tackle the joint issue of youth unemployment and inactivity, as well as the soaring benefits bill associated with it.

Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, was commissioned to examine the growing number of young people not in education, employment or training (Neet).

He said: “Among the hundreds of young people I have met in the last year, I have not found a single one of them who wanted to be Neet.”

His report recommends a series of changes to welfare, employment, education, and health which, over ten years, he estimates will help 440,000 more young people into sustained work, saving £3.6 billion a year.

“These changes will not be easy to make. Nor will they be pain-free,” writes Milburn, acknowledging some people could “get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim”.

His plan, should it be accepted by Andy Burnham’s government, will involve billions of public funds, kick-started with half a billion next year, being invested to create opportunities for those under 25 to get off benefits and into work.

In total, his reforms would need £5.8 billion a year in funding by 2036-37, offset by £3.6 billion of welfare savings and £2.4 billion of extra tax revenue from people in work.

“There will be people who will lose, but there’ll be many people who will gain,” said Alan Milburn.

Milburn says tackling the problem requires “radical” changes, but it was little over a year ago that similar changes proved too radical for Labour to stomach.

The party under Keir Starmer was forced to water down its welfare reform proposals in 2025 following a vocal rebellion from its own MPs.

The admission that vulnerable people could be worse off under these measures, even temporarily, as Milburn says, could still prove too hard a pill to swallow.

So what is the problem facing the country, and how does this report recommend the government solve it?

The number of Neets topped a million earlier this year for the first time in more than a decade. / Credit: iStock

The problem

Alan Milburn’s report says one in eight young people, totalling nearly one million, are not in education, employment or training.

Most are not looking for work, and six in ten have never had a job.

Across Europe, only Romania has a higher Neet rate than the UK, and the report sets out an ambition to reduce the UK rate by more than half, from 13% to around 5% by 2036.

The UK rate has never been lower than 9.7% since records began in 2001.

“Our country is at a fork in the road,” writes Milburn.

“Go on as we are and see the Neet crisis grow. Or change course and make the difficult changes that can shift the trajectory.

“This is a moment of choice for the country. Half measures will not do.”

Annual spending on health and disability benefits for young people has risen from £1.7 billion in 2019-20 to £4.7 billion in 2025-26.

This bill is currently forecast to rise again to £8.8 billion in 2036-37.

Welfare Reform

The report recommends creating a new “youth allowance” for under-25s, replacing their entitlement to the disability benefit personal independence payment (Pip) and the health element of Universal Credit.

The youth allowance would be set at the standard rate of Universal Credit for under-25s, with a higher rate for those living independently.

Accounting for those with more serious needs, the report also recommends additional payments be available for those who incur extra costs as a result of disability, and those who will never be able to work as a result of profound and long-term illness.

Spending on young people’s health and disability benefits is the fastest-growing part of the overall benefits bill, and it accounts for 13% of the total spend.

“By the time a young person ends up in the welfare system, something has often gone wrong far earlier in their lives,” writes Milburn.

Job Guarantees

Under current government rules, any young person classed as Neet for longer than 18 months is guaranteed a paid job of at least six months. This report recommends shortening the wait to 12 months.

The report also recommends an “opportunity guarantee”, which would offer a route into education, training or work, for every 18 to 24-year-old classed as Neet.

These would include:

  • A government-subsidised job
  • A further education place
  • Apprenticeships refocused on under-25s and Level 2 and 3 qualifications
  • Work placements of up to 12 weeks
  • Structured volunteering through a civic service
  • Help to start a business

The report aims to double the number of young people completing an apprenticeship over the decade, making apprenticeships a mainstream route for school leavers to rival university.

Those who refuse to engage with the help offered could lose the proposed youth allowance payments altogether.

Other reported recommendations include gradually cutting national insurance paid by businesses on workers aged under 25. / Credit: iStock

Cheaper Costs for Employers

Milburn acknowledged that policies introduced since Labour came into office in 2024 had contributed to the Neet problem by making it more expensive to hire younger workers.

The government has increased employers’ National Insurance costs and raised the minimum wage for younger workers at a faster rate than for older employees.

He said: “Well, there’s no doubt that that has hit business sentiment. Absolutely, no doubt at all… Employers have come to me and said that that has made it harder.”

In his report, Milburn stops short of a blanket reduction in employers’ National Insurance contributions for workers under 25, as had been anticipated before its publication.

Labour increased employers’ contributions under Keir Starmer, drawing criticism from opposition politicians and businesses facing higher costs.

Instead, the report recommends a five-year transition for 21 to 24-year-old workers, starting in retail and hospitality, during which the threshold for employers’ National Insurance contributions would rise from £5,000 to £10,000.

Milburn also recommends payments to employers to encourage them to hire younger workers, including £3,000 for hiring someone who has been Neet for six months.

Additional payments would include £2,000 for hiring care leavers or disabled people, £2,000 for firms with fewer than 50 staff, and £2,500 for apprenticeships.

“Labour’s policies have made it worse,” said Helen Whately, Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary.

What Has Been the Reaction?

The prime minister is expected to agree with the majority of Milburn’s recommendations. Burnham has already said the “status quo clearly isn’t working” and that his government is “ready to grasp the nettle here and make a better system for young people”.

Burnham met with Labour MPs shortly before Tuesday’s press conference in a bid to reassure a PLP that rejected welfare reforms just one year ago.

Dame Clare Moriarty, chief executive of Citizens Advice, described the report as “a watershed moment” and said change “must be done carefully”.

She said: “The government now has a huge opportunity, but with that comes risk. Young people must not be pushed into poverty as a result of changes to welfare.”

Labour backbenchers could have their own objections, while charities have voiced concern about cutting benefits intended to cover the extra costs of living with a disability.

Harriet Edwards from disability charity Sense said: “We share Alan Milburn’s ambition to break down the barriers that prevent young disabled people who want to work from doing so.”

But she added: “We urge the government to provide urgent reassurance that no young disabled person with complex needs will be left worse off.”

Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey blamed “successive governments” for the youth unemployment problem.

“No target or guarantee can conjure up jobs that don’t exist,” said Davey.

“The warning signs are there long before a young person leaves school. Our plan would shut off the NEETs pipeline at source, with 100 hours of real work experience before 18 and a careers coach for every young person.”

Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said: “We don’t need costly government schemes to fix Labour’s own mistakes.

“We need to stop making it so expensive and risky to hire young people.

“But Labour MPs who whacked business with the jobs tax, brought in the Employment Rights Act, and raised the minimum age for young people so high that business stopped hiring them, won’t vote for common sense.

“So sadly we won’t see any welfare savings under Andy Burnham, just more bluster and hot air.”

STV News is now on WhatsApp

Get all the latest news from around the country

Follow STV News
Follow STV News on WhatsApp

Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

WhatsApp channel QR Code
Posted in
    Last updated Nov 17th, 2026 at 11:41

    Today's Top Stories

    Popular Videos

    Latest in UK & International

    Trending Now