Man killed teacher after blackmailing her over sex with boy

A “cruel” cage fighter has been convicted of murdering his ex-partner after he blackmailed her about a sexual relationship she was having with a 15-year-old boy.

Jealous ex-convict Paul Robson, 50, snooped on teacher Caroline Kayll, 47, and the teenager outside her home in Linton, Northumberland, last November, and then launched a terrifying and sustained attack on them both.

Branded “a cruel and calculating coward” by the prosecution, Robson kicked Mrs Kayll in the head while wearing heavy work boots, and may have strangled her.

In his rage, he chopped off her hair in clumps and slashed her on the buttocks.

Paul Robson at a service station on the M74 travelling from Glasgow towards Linton, Northumberland, where Caroline Kayll was murdered (Crown Prosecution Service/PA)

She could not survive the catastrophic brain injuries he inflicted.

Robson also repeatedly attacked the boy with scissors and a meat cleaver, sprayed them both with ammonia and stole their phones – later updating her social media, pretending to be her, while he was on the run, Newcastle Crown Court was told.

He later messaged one of her friends to say: “I went up there and they are cuddled up on the sofa, watching TV.”

Nicholas Lumley QC, prosecuting, said: “He was never going to do anything other than ruin her.

“If his fury and his frustration got the better of him then he was going to take things further and end her life.”

The cage fighting coach and former MMA fighter denied murder, claiming it was the boy who attacked Mrs Kayll, and said he struggled to get the better of the less powerfully-built teenager in the ensuing brawl.

Robson had a clandestine relationship with Mrs Kayll while he was behind bars in HMP Northumberland.

They lived together but split up weeks before the murder and he blackmailed her when he found out about the illegal relationship she had started with the teenager, who cannot be identified.

Mr Lumley told the jury that Robson then had a hold over her, saying: “He knew things about her which she would not want to be made public.”

She was to confide in a friend that Robson was blackmailing her for £35,000 and that her ex was “going to ruin her” and tell her school, the jury heard.

Over 10 days in November, she transferred £29,000 to Robson and took out a £10,500 loan, having previously been solvent.

However, money was not enough for him, and on November 15, Robson drove three hours from Glasgow to Linton, having bought a locksmith’s bar, a magnetic GPS car tracker, screwdrivers, pliers, a wrench and the ammonia which he decanted into a washing-up liquid bottle.

CCTV showed him “prowling” outside her house.

Witnesses heard a female voice shout “get out” and later that evening Robson knocked on his former neighbour’s house to say “Caroline was in a bad way”, Mr Lumley said.

He then fled to Glasgow and remained at large while police made appeals to trace him before he was arrested.

He did not answer detectives’ questions but in a prepared statement said he was “broken” by her death and claimed someone attacked him when he visited her home.

Mr Justice Lavender will pass sentence at 2pm on Wednesday.

He told jurors they had seen some “very harrowing evidence” and they could be excused further jury service for 10 years.