Glasgow bin lorry disaster case opens as council sues First Bus

Glasgow City Council is suing First Bus, the former employers of the bin lorry driver Harry Clarke.

Bin lorry disaster: Glasgow's George Square in 2014. Andrew Milligan via PA Media
Bin lorry disaster: Glasgow's George Square in 2014.

A hearing has begun into the Glasgow bin lorry disaster which claimed the lives of six people.

Glasgow City Council is suing First Bus, the former employers of the bin lorry driver Harry Clarke, over the job reference the firm provided.

Mr Clarke collapsed while at the wheel of a bin lorry in the city centre in December 2014.

The vehicle hit pedestrians, killing six people and injuring more than a dozen others.


At a Court of Session hearing in Edinburgh on Tuesday, Roddy Dunlop QC, representing First Bus, and Andrew Smith QC, representing the local authority, took witness statements from medical professionals linked to Mr Clarke and his former employers.

The hearing heard Mr Clarke’s GP, Dr Gerard McKaig, confirm that he had been misled on Mr Clarke’s medical history prior to the crash.

Mr Clarke told his GP that he fainted in a warm canteen building in April 2010, but it later transpired that he had lost consciousness behind the wheel of a stationary bus, the case heard.

In a witness statement, Dr McKaig said had he known about Mr Clarke fainting behind the wheel of a bus, he would have “warranted a much fuller investigation” into his health at the time.


Witness statements were also given by the former clinical lead for Bupa’s occupational health services in Scotland, Dr Peter Warnock.

Dr Warnock told the hearing had he been made aware of Mr Clarke’s loss of consciousness behind the wheel in 2010, he would have deemed him “unfit for work” until a health investigation was carried out to the DVLA’s satisfaction.

The hearing continues into Monday afternoon.

A 2015 inquiry into the incident heard the tragedy took just 19 seconds to unfold.

Erin McQuade, 18, and her grandparents Jack Sweeney, 68, and Lorraine Sweeney, 69, from Dumbarton; Stephenie Tait, 29, and Jacqueline Morton, 51, both from Glasgow; and Gillian Ewing, 52, from Edinburgh, died in the crash.

A further 15 people were injured when the Glasgow City Council truck veered out of control.

It travelled along the pavement in Queen Street before crashing into the side of the Millennium Hotel in George Square.

FM calls for travellers arriving in Scotland to isolate for eight days

Nicola Sturgeon has called for urgent talks with the Prime Minister over the new Covid-19 variant.

ronstik via IStock

The First Minister has called on the Prime Minister to introduce a tougher four-nations approach to travel restrictions after six cases of the new Omicron variant were detected in Scotland.

In a joint-letter, Scotland’s First Minister Nicola Sturgeon and the First Minister of Wales Mark Drakeford called for a tightening of restrictions.

At a coronavirus briefing on Monday, Sturgeon explained that the proposed change would see people arriving in the UK from overseas being asked to self-isolate for a period of eight days.

They would then take a PCR test on day eight after their arrival, as well as on day two.

STV News
The letter to Boris Johnson signed by Nicola Sturgeon and Mark Drakeford. (Scottish Government)

The First Minister said: “We believe this measure would be more effective in identifying cases of this variant, which result from overseas travel and therefore help us prevent further community transmission from imported cases.

“Now, as we know from earlier stages of the pandemic with so many people travelling to Scotland, and indeed to Wales via airports in England, anything less than a four-nations approach to requirements like this will be ineffective, so we hope that a four-nations agreement can be reached.

“A four-nations approach obviously requires the four-nations to discuss these issues together and hear the best advice available.

“So Mark Drakeford and I have also called on the Prime Minister today to immediately convene a COBRA meeting with representation from each nation to discuss what additional steps we might have to consider and how we work together to tackle this new risk.”


Sturgeon also said confirmation has been sought that funding from the UK Treasury will be made available to any of the four nations in the event of further Covid protections being necessary.

She said: “Mark Drakeford and I are also conscious of the very real concern businesses and staff will feel at the possibility of further protections becoming necessary.

“Now, let me stress we all hope that this will not be necessary, but it is prudent to plan ahead and so we have also sought confirmation that should any further protections be necessary, Treasury funding would be available to any of the four nations that require to activate business support schemes.”

Six cases of new Covid-19 variant Omicron confirmed in Scotland

The Scottish Government revealed that six cases of the new variant have been identified.

4X-image via IStock
Covid-19: Six cases of new variant confirmed.

Six cases of the new Omicron variant of Covid-19 have been identified in Scotland.

The Scottish Government revealed the positive cases on Monday.

Four are in the Lanarkshire area and two have been identified in Greater Glasgow and Clyde.

Some of the new cases have no travel history, which suggests there is a degree of community transmission.


Public Health Scotland and local health protection teams are supporting those involved and contact tracing is being undertaken to establish the origin of the virus and any individuals they have come into contact with in recent weeks.

Health Secretary Humza Yousaf confirmed the news as he urged the public to “redouble their efforts”.

He said: “This will be a worrying time for the six people now identified as having the new variant.

“All will receive expert help and support and Public Health Scotland will undertake enhanced contact tracing in all cases.


“This will help establish the origin of the virus and any further individuals they have come into contact with in recent weeks.

“There is still much to learn about the Omicron variant. 

“Questions remain about its severity, transmissibility and response to treatments or vaccines and scientists are working at pace to provide additional information. Until more is known we must be cautious and do everything we can to minimise the risk of spreading infection.

“We have already taken steps and are aligning with the new border restrictions being introduced by the UK Government which will require fully vaccinated arrivals to take a PCR test within two days of arrival and to self-isolate until a negative result is received.

“These measures will be introduced as soon as possible and kept under constant review. However, we reserve the right to go further if necessary. We are also adopting the expanded red list of countries identified by the UK Government.

“This will also be kept under review.”

Yousaf also highlighted the need for a booster shot for those that are eligible.


He said: “We must now redouble our efforts to follow the basic rules that have served us well throughout the pandemic – wear a face covering on public transport and in all indoor settings for food and retail; open windows especially if you have people visiting at home; keep washing your hands regularly and thoroughly. 

“Work from home where possible, take regular lateral flow tests – especially before mixing with others outside your household.

“If you have symptoms, self-isolate and take a test and if contacted by Test and Protect or public health teams please co-operate and follow their advice. All close contacts of suspected Omicron cases will be advised to self-isolate for 10 days, regardless of their vaccination status.

“And of course, if you are eligible for your booster, or are still to have any dose of the Covid-19 vaccine, please get vaccinated now.”

Scotland’s Deputy First Minister John Swinney told BBC Good Morning Scotland: “We obviously have some travel history on some of the cases, I don’t have all of that detail available to me at this stage, but on some of the cases we are aware that there is no travel history involved on some of the cases.

“So what that tells us is that there must be a degree of community transmission of this particular strain of the virus in the absence of direct travel connection for some of the cases in the southern African area.

“So that obviously opens up further challenges for us in terms of interrupting the spread of this particular strain of the virus and that will be the focus of the contact tracing operation that is under way already.”

The first two cases in the UK – in Nottingham and Essex – were announced on Saturday, while a third Omicron case was detected in the UK on Sunday in a person with travel links to southern Africa.

Britain will convene an urgent meeting of G7 health ministers on Monday to discuss the variant first detected in South Africa amid concerns it could spread rapidly and partially evade existing jabs.

Man asked if he would ‘be on the news’ after raping disabled pensioner

Kyle McKenzie broke into the 83-year-old woman's house before attacking and raping her.

Oleksandr Filon via IStock
Rapist: Man attacked pensioner in her own home.

A masked sex attacker raped a disabled woman in her home – then later asked police if he would end up in the news.

Kyle McKenzie used a boulder to help him break into the 83-year-old victim’s house through a window as she lay in bed sleeping at around 5am.

He pulled the bed covers from her and said “do not scream – do not resist” while brandishing a garden tool.

A judge heard how the pensioner, who has a pacemaker and is registered disabled, tried to fight off McKenzie who punched her several times in the head during a struggle.


After he put the woman through a harrowing ordeal, the 23-year-old escaped out a window of the property in Glenrothes, Fife.

The widow managed to press her personal safety alarm and in a tearful call stated to a worker: “I have just been raped. Please – hurry, hurry.”

It was around a fortnight later before McKenzie was traced.

It emerged he had also broken into an elderly couple’s home shortly before the sex attack on June 25 last year.


After being charged, McKenzie stated to police: “Allegation of rape? That will ruin me.

“Are the papers going to know my name?”

First offender McKenzie now face a lengthy stint behind bars after he pled guilty to charges of rape and housebreaking.

He will return to the dock next month.

Prosecutor Graeme Jessop told how the rape victim was partially deaf, registered disabled and lived alone at her home.

Mr Jessop: “She observed a man wearing all black clothing and balaclava while brandishing a garden tool.

“He continued to pull the bed covers from the woman, who became frightened and began to resist.


“She grabbed his hand containing the weeding tool and discovered he was wearing rubber gloves.

“She began to struggle with McKenzie and was repeatedly punched to the head.”

The woman ended up on the floor at one stage.

She pleaded with the attacker: “You are going to kill me.”

He went on to rape the pensioner, who eventually managed to trigger her safety alarm.

Mr Jessop: “She describes ‘not being in this world’ for a number of minutes.”

It is thought McKenzie was spooked by the noise of the alarm and fled the scene.

An advisor at the Community Alarm Team at Fife Council managed to speak to the victim, who begged for help.

The woman was found to be “distressed, shocked and confused” when police initially met her.

She had suffered a number of bruises as a result of her ordeal.

DNA later linked McKenzie to the crime. 

The pattern from the sole of his Adidas trainers also matched a footwear mark found under the victim’s bedroom window.

Police discovered he had left a friend’s house in Kirkcaldy drunk hours before the rape.

This was a “relatively short distance” from the woman’s home and the house of a couple he stole a wine decanter from.

The hearing was told McKenzie lived between his brother’s house in Glenrothes and his girlfriend’s in Falkirk, Stirlingshire at the time.

McKenzie was remanded in custody by judge Lord Boyd and is due to be sentenced on December 20 in Edinburgh.

More on:

Ice weather warning as number of homes left without power

The yellow warning was issued by the Met Office.

draganab via IStock
A number of households have been left without power as a result of Storm Arwen.

A yellow warning for ice has been issued for the north-east of Scotland as cold weather sweeps the UK.

Drivers have been warned about some icy patches on untreated roads, whilst pedestrians and cyclists have been urged to take care on pavements and cycle paths.

The alert is in place until 10am on Monday.

Met Office via Website
Monday: A yellow weather warning for ice has been put in place.

It comes as thousands of residents living in areas badly impacted by Storm Arwen have been left without power.


Monday marked the third day for a number of people who had been impacted, whilst Scottish Water said on Sunday that around 3000 homes were without water supplies.

Energy firm SSE said it may take “several days” before power is fully restored to homes, adding the damage caused by Storm Arwen was ‘three times greater’ than the Beast from the East in 2018.

Schools in Aberdeenshire have also been closed for Monday and Tuesday to both pupils and staff due to the ongoing weather issues.

NHS Grampian also said that vaccination centres in Aberdeenshire would close on Monday and urged patients to rearrange appointments. 

Hundreds of seal pups killed at nature reserve in Storm Arwen

St Abb’s Head in the Scottish Borders is run by the National Trust for Scotland.

St Abb's Head National Nature Reserve via Facebook
St Abb’s Head: Hundreds of seal pups died in Storm Arwen.

Hundreds of seal pups have died at a nature reserve during Storm Arwen.

A spokesperson for St Abb’s Head in the Scottish Borders said they had “never seen” damage of such scale before.

They said in a small area of bay at Pettico Wick there were 224 dead pups in the water, with more washing ashore.

A further survey will be carried out this week on other colonies in the area, but the spokesperson said “it doesn’t look good”.


The nature reserve is run by the National Trust for Scotland.

In 2007 there was no colony at all, but last year it saw a record number of 1806 pups recorded.

In a post on Facebook, the spokesperson for St Abb’s Head said: “Having worked on seal colonies for ten years I’ve never seen a storm cause damage on anything like this scale before.

“Unfortunately it appears we have lost the majority of our seal pups to this storm.


“This is a risk grey seals take with their breeding strategy, pupping at this time of year when storms are most frequent.

“But for this kind of phenomenal storm to hit at the peak of pupping is exceptional.”

More than two thirds of people ‘support doubling child payment’

Campaigners said many families are facing a difficult winter.

Dominic Lipinski via PA Media
Poll: Calls to double the Scottish Child Payment.

More than two thirds of people think next month’s Scottish Government budget should be used to double a benefit payment made to poorer families, according to new research for anti-poverty campaigners.

The polling, conducted for the End Child Poverty coalition in Scotland, found that once “don’t knows” were excluded, 68% of people in Scotland support doubling the Scottish Child Payment, a £10-per-week-per-child benefit.

Coalition members said that many families are facing a really difficult winter and that next month’s draft budget is a “golden opportunity” to support them and raise the payment to £20.

The survey, carried out by Survation, found that even when people who responded “don’t know” were included, more than half (57%) of people agreed that the benefit should be doubled.


The Scottish Government has already pledged to increase the payment to £20 within the lifetime of the parliament and First Minister Nicola Sturgeon said in September that it will happen “sooner rather than later”.

Peter Kelly, director of Poverty Alliance, said: “In Scotland, people believe in protecting one another and in doing the right thing. As this new polling makes clear, they overwhelmingly support taking action now to stem the rising tide of child poverty.

“Children and families living in the grip of poverty right now simply cannot wait. Scottish ministers must listen to people across the country who are calling on them to do the right thing, and double the Scottish Child Payment now.”

The latest poll comes after more than 100 charities, faith groups and trade unions wrote to Finance Secretary Kate Forbes earlier this month urging her to use the upcoming draft budget to double the Scottish Child Payment.


The Scottish Child Payment is currently paid at £10 per week for each child under six in families in receipt of a qualifying benefit such as Universal Credit.

Commenting on the latest poll, Claire Telfer, head of Scotland, Save the Children, said: “We know that many families with young children in Scotland are struggling to make ends meet, parents are going without food or not putting the heating on, to care for their children.

“As a society we can – and must – do better. Next month’s budget is a golden opportunity to act now and support families and drive down poverty by doubling the Scottish Child Payment.”

The poll of 1045 people was carried out in mid-November.

Polly Jones, head of Scotland, Trussell Trust, said: “Families across Scotland are facing a really difficult winter. Right now, food banks in the Trussell Trust network in Scotland are giving out a food parcel every three minutes to people in crisis.

“This isn’t right, especially when we have the power to change this. Doubling the Scottish Child Payment now would be a huge boost to Scotland’s struggling families and I hope ministers will listen to the public and act.”

Other members of the End Child Poverty coalition in Scotland include Child Poverty Action Group in Scotland, Children in Scotland, Home Start, Barnardo’s, Children 1st, Oxfam, One Parent Families Scotland and Action for Children.


The Scottish Government is being asked for comment.

FM told to ‘back or sack’ health board bosses over infection scandal

Scottish Labour said Nicola Sturgeon must decide if she is 'on the side of bereaved families or managers'.

SNS Group via SNS Group
Hospital: Scottish Labour call on Nicola Sturgeon to 'back or sack' hospital bosses.

Calls for health board bosses to be sacked over the deadly infection scandal at Glasgow’s flagship hospital will be debated at Holyrood this week.

Scottish Labour will lead a debate on Wednesday to renew calls for senior management of the NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (NHSGGC) health board to be sacked as a result of the infection scandal at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (QEUH).

Leader Anas Sarwar last week demanded that First Minister Nicola Sturgeon bring the hospital under direct ministerial control and sack senior management figures amid concern about waterborne infections at QEUH.

At First Minister’s Questions, Sarwar revealed that a further two deaths at the hospital may have been linked to the infected water supply.


Sturgeon argued that “sacking a health board does not change overnight the practice in a hospital”.

But Sarwar has now called on the First Minister to “decide if she is on the side of bereaved families and bullied clinicians, or out-of-touch managers” when the motion is debated in the Scottish Parliament.

He said: “The ongoing scandal at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital is the greatest of the devolution era, but the SNP government has failed to act.

“Lives have been lost, families have been shattered and whistle-blowers have been put under incredible strain.


“In any other country, there would be resignations and sackings. But under this SNP government, it has been nothing but denial and cover-up.

“This must be a line in the sand, Nicola Sturgeon must decide if she is on the side of bereaved families and bullied clinicians, or out-of-touch managers.

“She has a straight choice on the leadership of the health board – back them or sack them.

“That’s why this week in Parliament, Scottish Labour will give all parties the chance to do right by the families affected and vote to send a message to this Government that words are not enough.”

Responding to Sarwar, Sturgeon said: “When concerns are raised about the cause of someone’s death, then that has to be properly investigated so that the action that is then taken as a result of that is the right action.”

While she accepted “these are serious matters”, she added: “We do not do justice to the families concerned if we simply call for action that is not based on proper investigation, proper scrutiny and proper consideration.”

Following FMQs, a spokesperson for NHSGGC said: “In the past 24 hours, the QEUH/RHC (Royal Hospital for Children) and specifically the treatment provided to our patients has continued to be called into question.


“Hearing such speculation and allegations has been extremely difficult for our staff and patients alike.”

The spokesperson said the continued claims that NHSGGC was failing to be transparent across all areas of patient care and building safety were “of serious concern”.

Silverburn owners in talks over selling shopping centre for £140m

Silverburn, based in Pollok, Glasgow, was originally bought by Hammerson for around £300m in 2009.

STV News
Silverburn: Could be sold for £140m.

Retail property giant Hammerson is in talks over the sale of the Silverburn shopping centre near Glasgow for around £140m.

Shares in the company moved higher on Monday after it confirmed talks over the disposal of the site, which is a 50-50 joint venture Hammerson holds with the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board (CPPIB).

Silverburn, based in Pollok, Glasgow, was originally bought by Hammerson for around £300m in 2009.

However, the owner of Birmingham’s Bullring has been weighed down by dwindling valuations for retail properties in recent years.


It told investors in August that its short-term priority is to sell non-core parts of its real estate portfolio.

The group said any sale would help to strengthen its balance and enable it to “recycle capital for investment”.

Hammerson sold its remaining retail parks operation, which included sites in Middlesbrough and Falkirk, to Canadian investor Brookfield for £330m as part of its disposal programme.

In a statement, Hammerson said: “There can be no certainty that a transaction will take place, but the company confirms the pricing under discussion is £140m, which would represent a class 2 transaction.


“The company will provide a further update in due course, if appropriate.”

It comes after Hammerson revealed last month that the number of shoppers heading to its sites has improved to between 15% and 20% below pre-Covid levels.

Shares in Hammerson were 3.1% higher at 31.42p after the markets opened on Monday morning.

Suspect charged and due in court after man stabbed in murder bid

Police launched an investigation after a 24-year-old man was found seriously injured following a disturbance in East Kilbride.

Richard Johnson via IStock
Police: A suspect has been charged following an incident in East Kilbride last week.

A suspect has been charged after a man was stabbed in an attempted murder in South Lanarkshire.

Police launched an investigation after a 24-year-old man was found seriously injured following a disturbance in East Kilbride’s Calderwood Square on Wednesday, November 24.

On Monday, the force confirmed a man had been arrested and charged in connection with the incident.

A Police Scotland spokesperson said: “A 29-year-old man has been arrested and charged in connection with the attempted murder of a 24-year-old man who was found seriously injured in Calderwood Square, East Kilbride, on Wednesday, November 24.


“He is due to appear at Hamilton Sheriff Court on Monday, November 29.”

More on:

You're up to date

You've read today's top stories. Where would you like to go next?