Drug dealer 'wrongly convicted' of raping girl, 14, as juror knew him

The Court of Criminal Appeal in Edinburgh heard the juror should have disclosed she lived 'six doors down' from Shaun Miller's family as a teenager

Drug dealer ‘wrongly convicted’ of raping girl, 14, as juror knew himAdobe Stock

A drug dealer serving time for raping a 14-year-old girl was wrongly convicted of the assault because a juror allegedly failed to disclose she knew him, a court heard.

A lawyer for Shaun Miller, 35, told the Court of Criminal Appeal in Edinburgh on Thursday that a woman juror should have disclosed that she lived “six doors down” from Miller’s family in Easterhouse, Glasgow, when she was a teenager.

The Court of Criminal Appeal in Edinburgh heard on Thursday how the woman also knew members of Miller’s family and was associated with him in the Glasgow estate when she was a young girl. 

Advocate Edith Forrest KC told appeal judges Lord Beckett, Lord Matthews and Lord Clark that the woman failed to disclose her past relationship with Miller at the start of his trial last year. 

She said the juror’s failure to tell court officials of her past associations with Miller created the impression of bias and made her client’s conviction unsafe. 

Ms Forrest said: “There’s a real possibility that the tribunal was biased. 

“The evidence does demonstrate the real possibility that the conviction is unsafe.”

Ms Forrest made the argument in her closing submission in an evidential hearing which was heard before the court on Thursday. 

She is representing Miller, who was given a seven-year term in July 2025 for rape following proceedings at the High Court in Glasgow. He was also told he’d be supervised for two years following his release from custody. 

On that occasion, the court heard how Miller preyed on his victim after inviting the child and her friends back to his then-flat in Glasgow in December 2019.

The court heard how the girl had been out with friends in Glasgow’s Gorbals area that night.

Miller then agreed to buy them alcohol from a local Spar shop after they gave him money.

He asked them back to his home and went on to provide cocaine when they arrived.

The girl recalled Miller “pestering” her, and she was said to have felt “distinctly uncomfortable”.

He persuaded her to stay by claiming he would arrange for a taxi to take her and a friend home later.

The cab arrived, but it had to turn back after it emerged that Miller had not arranged payment for the fare.

She ended up back at Miller’s flat and eventually fell asleep, and awoke to Miller raping her.

Edith Forrest KC, defending, said Miller continued to have the support of relatives.

Sentencing, Judge Kelly said it was to the girl’s “misfortune” that she and a friend has to return to Miller’s home.

He stated: “I assess your culpability as significant. There was a considerable age gap between you and her. You were 28, she was 14.”

The court heard Miller was deemed at high risk of similar offending.

He was put on the sex offenders list as well as being banned from approaching or contacting the victim, both for an indefinite period.

Miller appeared at the High Court in Edinburgh in May 2025 and was given a five-year term for being involved in the drugs trade.

He was caught with £1.1m of heroin after an operation which saw police targeting a major crime gang.

On that occasion, the court heard how he leased a garage at an industrial yard in Glasgow where officers found the 23-kilo haul of the Class A drug, along with 98 kilos of cannabis resin worth £176,940.

Miller was also linked to cocaine recovered by police during a search of a house in Rutherglen, in South Lanarkshire, which had a potential value of £125,500 if sold in street deals.

Miller, formerly of Glasgow, earlier admitted being involved in serious organised crime between September 6, 2024 and January 10, 2025 at addresses in the city, Rutherglen and Coatbridge.

He was involved in the sale and supply of heroin, cocaine and cannabis, including transportation, storage and distribution, and possession of criminal property – money from drug dealing.

A judge told Miller that she would have jailed him for seven and a half years for the drugs offences if he was convicted after a trial, but would reduce the sentence following his guilty plea.

The judge told him that the jail sentence for the drugs offences would be served consecutively to a current prison term.

On Thursday, the female juror gave evidence at the hearing. The 32-year-old juror told the court that she didn’t recognise Miller at proceedings. 

She said that on day two, a court official took her aside from other members of the jury and asked her if she knew Miller. She responded ‘no’ and the case continued with her serving. 

She said in evidence that she had brothers who knew of Miller and that one of her relatives told her about the accused following the conviction. 

In his closing submission, prosecutor Chris McKenna told the appeal court that there was no evidence available to show a miscarriage of justice had taken place.

He added that Miller’s lawyers had failed to show that the juror had acted inappropriately or that anything unlawful or illegal happened. 

He added: “I would suggest that on the basis of the evidence presented to the court that there has been no miscarriage of justice.”

Lord Beckett thanked lawyers for their submissions. 

He added: “We will take time to consider matters and we will issue a judgment in due course.”

STV News is now on WhatsApp

Get all the latest news from around the country

Follow STV News
Follow STV News on WhatsApp

Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

WhatsApp channel QR Code
Posted in

Today's Top Stories

Popular Videos

Latest in Glasgow & West

Trending Now