The city accounted for around a third of Scotland’s 1187 drug deaths in 2018 – among Europe’s highest and the most in the UK – something Aitken said needed an “emergency response”.
But opening Thursday’s conference, Malthouse said evidence of the concept working in other countries is “mixed”.
He said: “There are two issues with DCRs – first we cannot pretend they’re not legally very difficult.
“They involve the commission of several types of crime and the tolerance therefore of those crimes and that presents us with a legal and legislative difficulty.
“Secondly, the evidence around the world is mixed – most of the studies are broadly to areas where they’ve been used and even the most successful ones affect quite small numbers of people.”
The UK crime minister added: “I am concerned that it is a distraction from the main event, which is fundamentally there needs to be more concentration and resource on innovative and different kinds of treatments and that making sure we deal with underlying and complex health concerns is critical.
‘Given the scale of the deaths we need scalable solutions. In some parts of the country like Dundee, for example, I’m not sure a DCR would necessarily be appropriate – so what are we going to do for Dundee?’
Kit Malthouse, UK crime minister
“It’s part of the debate. There’s a difference between thinking about the debate and pulling from it what you think you can do and people having different views.
“Given the scale of the deaths we need scalable solutions. In some parts of the country like Dundee, for example, I’m not sure a DCR would necessarily be appropriate – so what are we going to do for Dundee?”
By council area, Dundee City Council has the highest number of drug deaths per head of population over the last four years of figures.
Malthouse said he could not remember a time when drugs were “so profoundly behind the many social problems we face as a country”.
But he expressed hope the summit would be the start of ongoing cooperation on the issue of drug deaths, calling a cross-border policing round-table between English forces and Police Scotland to tackle the drug trade’s “business model”.
Malthouse went on: “We’re running at the moment in England pilots in Merseyside, the West Midlands and London which are showing some success.
“I’m quite keen to stimulate activity between the two and I’m hoping that Humza (Yousaf) will agree to a joint round-table so we can put the two or whatever it is forces together and talk more about what we can do – particularly around somewhere like Dundee which is a discreet community that’s got an acute problem.”
Yousaf, the Scottish justice secretary, may also be involved in another summit due to happen next month.
It comes as the Scottish Government an extra £20m of funding to tackle drug deaths to coincide with the summits, on top of the £7.3m already set aside for the issue in the draft Budget.
The cash will help deliver the recommendations of the drug deaths task force, provide investment for mental health support and allow officials to consider adding more NHS-funded drug rehab beds.
Public health minister Joe FitzPatrick said: “The UK Government has made it clear at their summit that they are not willing to consider the bold, innovative approaches to this problem that I feel are needed.
“However, that doesn’t mean we will stop fighting for what we believe is right and this extra investment will help us in our efforts to save lives.”
Representatives from addiction charity FAVOR (Faces & Voices of Recovery) UK protested outside the summit venue with a banner of their campaign slogan: “You keep talking we keep dying.”
Annemarie Ward, from the charity, told STV News: “It just feels like we’re having reviews about reviews and talking shops.
“No one’s actually doing anything to change the situation or to help people who are dying.”
She added: “Both events have raised the debate and that’s a positive thing, but it’s not enough.”
I know, I know, you’re desperate to know where Storm Ellen is/ has been/ has gone – depending on what you think has happened to her.
Some of you may be slightly confused, she swung by last weekend, right? Wrong. You may remember last week I was talking about the potential for a weekend storm which would be unnamed. Well after tweeting about it, lots of people replied saying it was actually called Storm Ellen.
That, however, was a mix-up due to some of the press deciding to name it themselves, without it ever officially being named by the Met teams. This is one of the problems we have with issuing the names in advance – sometimes someone just takes it upon themselves to name an upcoming storm before anything has been done officially.
But does that matter? Well, yes in this case, it did, because the ‘storm’ came to nothing in the end as it didn’t really develop like some computer models were touting. So Met Eirann and the Met Office were right not to name it Ellen and worry people unnecessarily.
Something to confuse you more is we’ve got Storm Jorge (pronounced Horhay) on the way this weekend. But I hear you say, why then has the storm changed sex as it hurtles towards us with a set of castanets? Well that’s more down to timing. Met Eireann was considering this morning naming the storm Ellen, the next name on our joint list with the Irish service, but they were pipped to the post by the Spanish State Meteorological Agency. The Spanish met service is part of the south-west European storm naming group, along with France and Portugal. That means, like our partnership with the Irish, they have their own joint agreed list of yearly names they work through.
It’s convention that once a storm has been named by any country, that the name will then be passed on through other countries the track takes it, even though they might have their own list of storm names. It’s the same as when the National Hurricane Centre in Florida names tropical storms or hurricanes – we refer to them here as ‘ex tropical storm …’ rather than rename them when they cross the Atlantic and head towards us.
Now we’ve cleared that up, what does Jorge have in store for Scotland? Well in actual fact not too much. The storm centre is expected to currently track right over Scotland, which means most of us will have light winds. The strongest winds will be around the edges of the centre for Shetland and Orkney, Kintrye, Islay, and Dumfries and Galloway where gusts could reach up to 70mph along the coast.
The track may change which would give us much stronger winds, so keep an eye out for the latest information in the forecast. There will also be more rain moving north on Saturday, which, of course, because it’s a leap year will just add more to the rainfall totals of what has been a record-breaking wet month for some spots.
Schools have been told there is “no need to close” if any pupils or staff are showing symptoms of coronavirus.
Preparations are being stepped up across Scotland as more and more positive cases are declared in mainland Europe and the rest of the UK.
Steps which should be taken in schools to avoid the virus spreading have now been released by NHS Scotland.
The advice details how teachers and staff can best deal with the issue and what measures to take to avoid it spreading among pupils and relatives at home.
Schools have been advised to contact their local health protection team for advice if anyone is showing symptoms before issuing any wider communications while also bearing in mind the confidentiality of the person who is unwell.
There is no further action school staff should take until the test results are known, and then the individual will be given advice on if and when they should return.
However if any child, pupil, student or staff member within the institution is diagnosed with COVID-19 then further action will be taken to identify anyone who had been in close contact .
Anyone thought to have been in contact with someone showing symptoms who has since been diagnosed will be asked to self-isolate at home.
Who is considered a ‘contact’?
Any child, pupil, student or staff member in close face-to-face or touching contact with the patient;
Those working alongside them within two metres for 15 minutes or longer;
Anyone who has talked to them or has been coughed;
Anyone who has cleaned up any bodily fluids of the individual;
Close friendship groups and any child, pupil, student or staff member living in the same household as a confirmed case.
Any pupil, student or staff member who has visited any of the worst affected or category 1 risk areas since February 19, but who are not showing symptoms, should isolate themselves for around 14 days.
A van driver who killed a pensioner in a head-on crash after a dangerous overtaking manoeuvre in a storm has been jailed for five years.
Andrew McKinley, 26, from Kilmarnock, was convicted at the High Court in Glasgow of causing the death of Jean Shearer, 70, who was a passenger in her husband Walter’s Smart car in December 31, 2017, by dangerous driving.
Mr Shearer, 80, was also seriously hurt in the collision which took place around 11am on the A737 near Dalry, Ayrshire.
The Shearers were on their way to to visit their daughter, when McKinley’s Peugeot van struck them.
Storm Dylan was raging at the time and there was surface water on the road.
When McKinley pulled out to overtake his van aqua planed. He lost control and ended up on the wrong side of the road.
His van ploughed into the Smart car being driven by Mr Shearer. Mrs Shearer died seven days later in Crosshouse Hospital, Irvine.
Judge Johanna Johnson banned McKinley from driving for seven years on Thursday and told him: “You were aware of those conditions and you engaged in a course of dangerous driving through Dalry and overtook the car and drove at an extensive speed.
“Your actions have devastated a whole family and there is no sentence this court could ever impose that would reduce in any way the grief and loss felt by the Shearer family.”
“Jean was a lovely person and beautiful lady. She would help other people.”
Walter Shearer, Jean’s husband
Outside court Jean’s husband Walter blasted the jail term as “totally inadequate”.
An emotional Mr Shearer paid tribute to his wife, saying: “I’m first and foremost disappointed at the sentence – it was inadequate and doesn’t compare to the damage and death that he caused through dangerous driving.
“Jean was a lovely person and beautiful lady. She would help other people.
“Five years in my opinion is totally inadequate and it should be longer and I like to think we could appeal it.
“It is only the Crown that can appeal it and not the victims which doesn’t make it a level playing field – it’s unfair.”
The court heard that the cause of Mrs Shearer’s death was broncho-pneumonia and chest injuries due to road traffic collision.
Her husband suffered fractured ribs, and a broken leg. He did not give evidence as he has no memory of the crash.
McKinley sobbed and said “I’m sorry” to the Shearer family who were in the public gallery as he was led to custody.
He was previously convicted in December 2013 of careless driving and in February 2014 for dangerous driving and banned for two years.
Michael Gove echoed Dad’s Army as he told the SNP “they don’t like it up ’em”, accusing their MPs of being intent on “smashing up the United Kingdom”.
In a fiery Commons exchange, the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster used the catchphrase of the character Lance Corporal Jones, played by the late Clive Dunn, adding that some SNP MPs were “decent and kind people” but still “nationalists”.
a statement on the UK’s negotiating mandate with the EU, SNP MP Steven Bonnar
called for a second Scottish independence referendum.
Chryston and Bellshill MP added: “Does he truly believe withholding the
sovereign right of the Scottish people is a sustainable position going
In his response, Gove mislabelled the Scottish National Party as the “Scottish nationalist party” at which point SNP MPs interrupted, shouting “national, national”.
A gunman admitted pointing a loaded pistol at two bouncers in a busy Glasgow street.
At the High Court in Glasgow, 32-year-old Francis Smith pleaded guilty to pulling the weapon – a Slovakian manufactured Grand Power self-loading pistol – on Benjamin Bibby and Stewart Edwards at Nico’s in Sauchiehall Street on December 21, last year.
admitted two contraventions of the firearms act.
Angela Gray told the court that minutes earlier there was an incident in which
Smith was allegedly assaulted outside the bar.
She said: “The accused shouted ‘I’m going to get a gun and shoot you’. The threat was not taken seriously.”
The court was
shown a video of Smith, who was wearing a red baseball cap, returning
minutes later armed with a gun.
He had grabbed the handgun which he kept wrapped in a towel in a chest of drawers in his room at the Blue Triangle accommodation in nearby Holland Street, Glasgow and headed back to the bar.
Ms Gray said:
“Given that it was the week of Christmas, Sauchiehall Street was busy with
“As the accused
approached Nico’s bar he was holding the handgun.
“Someone in the
vicinity shouted ‘gun’ as a warning. With his arm outstretched the accused
pointed the handgun towards Mr Bibby and Mr Edwards.
immediately approached the accused and began to wrestle the handgun from him.
He was assisted by Mr Edwards and another door steward.
was disarmed and restrained on the ground until police arrived.”
Smith’s room and found a single bulleted cartridge on the floor, five
cartridges in a money tin and a further five inside a knotted latex glove.
When the gun
was pointed at two bouncers there was a live cartridge in the magazine and when
it was first examined by firearms officers the safety catch was off.
The gun was
found to be in good working order and capable of discharging bulleted
Ms Gray added:
“All the bulleted cartridges recovered from the accused’s address were also
apparently live and suitable for use with the handgun.”
Smith has no
criminal convictions of note. His record relates only to drinking alcohol in a
Defence QC John
Scullion said: “Given the circumstances a custodial sentence is inevitable.”
Murphy QC deferred sentence on Smith until next month for background reports
and remanded him in custody.
The partner of Motherwell FC manager Stephen Robinson wrote to prosecutors saying he should not have been charged with assaulting her, a court has heard.
Robyn Lauchlan’s letter said the incident leading to his arrest was a “misunderstanding” as he was trying to ensure her safety.
The letter was read out as Robinson, 45, went on trial at Edinburgh Sheriff Court accused of assaulting Ms Lauchlan on Waverley Bridge in the city on December 13 last year.
Robinson is accused of grabbing her, pushing and pulling her and pinning her against a fence.
The football manager, who denies both charges, is further accused of behaving in a threatening or abusive manner by shouting, swearing and acting aggressively.
Robinson’s lawyer, Susan Duff, read part of Ms Lauchlan’s letter to the procurator fiscal service to court.
It stated she was writing to “advise you of a misunderstanding which has taken place” leading to the case.
She wrote: “Under no circumstances did my partner do anything to justify his arrest given that he was trying to secure my safety.”
Ms Lauchlan said she was intoxicated after having four glasses of wine in a bar in Edinburgh and became distressed after a man who had been speaking to Robinson there told her to shut up and Robinson did not intervene.
She said she stormed away and was refusing to go to the station with Robinson.
“In my emotional state I aggressively accused Stephen of not defending me,” she wrote.
“At this point Stephen was mortified by my dramatic overreaction to a minor issue and followed me through the (Christmas) market to ensure my safety.”
She added: “He took my hands to calm me down. Under no circumstances did Stephen grab me with aggressive intent.”
Ms Lauchlan wrote that she left, later meeting Robinson in Waverley Station.
She added: “I was so relieved to see him and I just wanted to cuddle him and go home.”
Ms Lauchlan said she saw two girls spot the incident and said she felt “guilty and humiliated to have put my partner in that situation”, given how they would perceive it.
She wrote she realises Robinson chose to ignore the man in the bar to avoid creating an atmosphere and she should not have expected him to apologise.
Witness Felicity Underdown, 19, told the court she saw the pair at around 7.30pm on December 13 outside the Waverley Bridge entrance to the Christmas market.
She said the woman looked “terrified” as Robinson “caged” her against a fence with his arms, “screaming in her face”.
Ms Underdown said: “She was crying, there were tears all down her face and she was shaking.”
She said Robinson grabbed the woman and pulled her and was swearing but she could not recall what was being said.
Ms Underdown said she shouted: “Get your f****** hands off her” at Robinson but they paid no notice.
She alerted security guards who called police.
Questioned by Ms Duff, who read Ms Lauchlan’s letter to her, the witness agreed if Ms Lauchlan disagreed with her version of events she could be “mistaken” and Ms Lauchlan’s version would be the truth.
The trial before Sheriff John Cook continues.
You're up to date
You've read today's top stories. Where would you like to go next?