The Scottish Government’s ferry procurement arm does not want a direct award of contracts to Ferguson Marine, MSPs have been told.
In March, former deputy first minister Kate Forbes announced four new vessels – two of which will be small ferries to serve islands on the west coast – would be directly awarded to the Port Glasgow yard, subject to a “due diligence exercise”.
The yard, which is the last commercial shipbuilder on the Clyde, was saved from administration by the Scottish Government in 2019 but has been at the centre of a political firestorm as a result of repeated delays and cost overruns to the Glen Sannox and the yet-to-be-delivered Glen Rosa.
In a letter to Transport Scotland, the chief executive of Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited (CMAL) said the direct award of the vessels was “problematic at best and folly at worst”.
Appearing before the Transport Committee on Wednesday, Kevin Hobbs said: “If you’re asking me the opinion of CMAL and the board, then whilst we want to see that shipyard survive, we do not believe building ferries there is the right thing to do for the island communities because we have witnessed, as you’re very well aware, that the current vessels that they’re building have not been either value for money and they have been heavily delayed.
“We would not want that to happen to the small vessel replacement programme (SVRP).
“Those ships really need to arrive in a very, very timely manner and that is the reason.
“It’s not that we don’t want a near neighbour, and they are a near neighbour of ours, to survive.
“But commercially, I do not believe, and we do not believe as a board, that we ought to be building ferries there at this point in time because we need them at pace and we need them to be value for money, and we don’t think either of those will be the case as it stands today.”
Asked if he would rather the direct award was not made to Ferguson, Mr Hobbs added: “100%. We have written to the Government and told them that.”
The two new vessels – which would form part of the second phase of the SVRP – would serve the Sound of Harris and the Sound of Barra.
The letter from Mr Hobbs was later read out in the committee by member Graham Simpson.
According to Mr Simpson, the letter said the costs at Ferguson would “far outweigh” those that could be achieved by an open contest, adding that CMAL had “intractable concerns” about the possibility of delays.
The letter added: “For any one of these reasons and in any combination, the board may reasonably consider that the proposed direct award is problematic at best and folly at worst.
“The CMAL board feels strongly that the detriment to the island communities of a direct award to Ferguson’s far outweighs the planned benefit to the workforce of Inverclyde.”
But in a sometimes-tense appearance before the same committee on Wednesday, Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn said the Scottish Government remained committed to directly awarding the contracts.
Flynn said: “I believe it is absolutely right that we put our confidence in Ferguson’s as the last commercial shipbuilder on the Clyde to be able to deliver these vessels for the island communities to ensure that we have resilience within the network, the resilience that they deserve, and I believe that builds upon the extensive programme that we have already undertaken to date.
“I am extremely confident in the yard and its ability to deliver and I think it’s fundamentally important that the Scottish Government delivers a future for Ferguson’s and delivers for the islanders.”
The transport secretary added that the impact of losing the Ferguson Marine yard on the communities in Inverclyde would be “stark”.
Transport Scotland chief executive Alison Irvine told the committee the due diligence exercise should be complete by the end of March next year.
Reacting to the comments from Mr Hobbs, Ferguson Marine chief executive Graeme Thomson said the yard’s “recent past does not define our future”.
He added: “Ferguson Marine has built ships on the Clyde for more than a century, and its vessels have served communities around the world.
“This includes almost a third of vessels currently operating as part of the CalMac fleet, many of which are serving well beyond their expected lifespan. Glen Sannox is now in service with Glen Rosa due to follow shortly, and we have learned hard lessons from that programme.
“Today’s Ferguson Marine has new leadership, stronger governance, greater programme management control and a skilled workforce ready to deliver.
“Building ferries at Port Glasgow keeps skilled jobs in the local area and keeps shipbuilding skills alive on the Clyde, from apprentices to experienced tradespeople.
“If these skills are lost, we cannot get them back. Decisions on procurement are a matter for the Scottish Government.
“Our recent past does not define our future and our focus remains on showing that our yard can and will build Scotland’s ferries well, on time and to budget.”
Follow STV News on WhatsApp
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

PA Media




















