Watchdog urges more transparency on cost and timing of public sector reforms

The Auditor General said the Scottish Government needs to provide more detail.

Watchdog urges more transparency on cost and timing of public sector reformsPA Media

A watchdog has called for more transparency from Government on proposed public sector reforms.

The Scottish Government has embarked on a programme of significant change to public services, including reorganising councils and the NHS.

But ministers have come under fire since announcing the plans for not laying out more detail.

On the NHS, work is under way to replace the current 14 territorial health boards with just two covering the east and west of the country.

The Government has been unable to say how much the initial shift will cost and how much it will save in the long run.

The council proposals are likely to take longer than the NHS, with the Government seeking to consult with local government on future structures.

As an opening salvo, ministers suggested a two-tier system of up to 160 hyper-local councils along with between six and 10 regional bodies, which could have more powers.

The Government has insisted it is open to working with councils to decide on the future structure.

In a report covering the Government’s accounts for last year, Auditor General Stephen Boyle said: “There needs to be more transparency on the public service reform plans, including timelines and the expected impact on finances and service delivery.

“Further, lessons must be learned from previous large-scale reorganisation and reform, including the creation of Police Scotland and the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service.”

The accounts, which come against a tight fiscal backdrop as the Government seeks to tackle a near-£5 billion black hole in its budget by the end of the decade, showed an underspend last year of £591 million of the £64.2 billion in its coffers.

The Auditor General added: “Alongside economic growth, public service reform is critical to securing the long-term financial sustainability of Scotland’s public services.

“These changes need to be delivered at scale and pace given the extent of the financial challenges Scotland faces.

“Ministers also need to give more details on the public service reform proposals within the Programme for Government.

“That includes timelines and the expected impact of actions on the public finances and service delivery.”

Scottish Tory finance spokesman Craig Hoy said: “This is a damning verdict on John Swinney’s back-of-a-fag-packet proposals for Scotland’s public services.

Scottish Tory MSP Craig Hoy hit out at the ‘back-of-a-fag-packet’ reform plans PA Media
Scottish Tory MSP Craig Hoy hit out at the ‘back-of-a-fag-packet’ reform plans 

“Independent auditors have made it clear that they are shrouded in secrecy, and SNP ministers need to urgently outline how they will be delivered.

“SNP economic incompetence has resulted in a looming £5 billion black hole in Scotland’s finances, yet Swinney still refuses to rein in his out-of-control benefits bill.

“On top of that, the nationalists are still short-changing Scotland’s struggling public services to the tune of nearly £600 million.”

Scottish Labour public service reform spokeswoman Carol Mochan said her party is willing to work with the Government on reforms, “but John Swinney needs to start providing answers to a growing list of questions”.

She added: “Ministers have rushed ahead with their proposals for reforming the NHS, social care, and local government without addressing some of the fundamental challenges we face.

“Scottish Labour is supportive of reform that will help drive efficiency, but we do not want a situation where power is centralised. We believe it must be pushed out into local communities, into the hands of decision makers who know best.

“It is also imperative that the Government engages constructively with trade unions and workers to ensure that their rights are protected, including by providing a clear timeline for any changes to the workforce that are proposed.”

Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth said: “This Government continues to manage its budget responsibly and this latest set of published accounts have been given a clean bill of health by the Auditor General.

“Our approach has ensured that we focus resources on key priorities, such as easing cost-of-living pressures, eradicating child poverty and improving the country’s public services.

“The accounts show an underspend of around £591 million, 0.9% of our overall budget, demonstrating our robust financial management practices, with £358 million, 0.6% of the budget, available to carry forward to the following year.

“Some non-cash budgets, such as depreciation, cannot be carried forward, but not a penny of cash has been handed back to HM Treasury in the 2025-26 budget.

“The Scottish Government’s commitment to public service reform is about ensuring that public services are good quality, efficient, effective, and sustainable for generations to come.

“We know the upcoming Scottish Budget for 2027-28 leaves us with tough decisions given the challenging fiscal environment and real terms £650 million cut delivered to the block grant by the UK Chancellor, but I am determined to ensure that our spending priorities will protect the most vulnerable in society.”

Reform UK public service reform spokesman Max Bannerman said: “The Auditor General’s report confirms that while the SNP makes ambitious statements about savings, they aren’t willing to establish any practical targets to make it happen.

“Ivan McKee is the only SNP minister with any business experience but he is being routinely kneecapped by his colleagues to keep secrets about budget specifics and defend the indefensible.

“Clarity and forward-planning are the only ways to reduce the fiscal deficit black hole the SNP has spent the last 20 years creating.”

Scottish Lib Dem finance spokesman Liam McArthur said the plans were “desperately undercooked”.

“After decades of mediocre economic performance, the forthcoming budget needs to place a significant emphasis on growth,” he said.

“My party does not want to see the can kicked down the road. Ministers need to explain exactly how they will get the Scottish economy moving at last.”

STV News is now on WhatsApp

Get all the latest news from around the country

Follow STV News
Follow STV News on WhatsApp

Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

WhatsApp channel QR Code
Last updated Nov 19th, 2026 at 20:53

Today's Top Stories

Popular Videos

Latest in Politics

Trending Now