Swinney warns of 'significant financial implications' of Milburn review

The review proposed sweeping changes to get more young people back to work.

Swinney warns of ‘significant financial implications’ of Milburn reviewPA Media

John Swinney has described a proposed package of reforms to get young people into work as a “substantial contribution”, but warned it could see Scotland receive less money.

The long-awaited report from former Labour minister Alan Milburn was released on Tuesday, detailing sweeping changes at a UK level aimed at getting the one million people not in education, employment or training – described as Neets – into the labour market.

Changes to the benefits system proposed in the plan would see a cut of £3.6 billion to the welfare bill, which would likely see a drop in money given to Scotland to fund its own social security if it is not spent in other devolved areas.

Asked about the review in Holyrood on Tuesday by Labour economy spokesman Daniel Johnson, the First Minister said: “There is a great deal in the Milburn review that the Government will consider – I think it is a substantial contribution to the debate.”

Mr Swinney said some elements of the proposals were already in place in Scotland, but added: “There are potentially some significant financial implications that could be negative for the Scottish Government – we need to explore those in great detail.

“It depends, of course, on the reaction of the United Kingdom Government, but I do assure Mr Johnson that the Scottish Government will consider carefully all of the contents of the Milburn review and relate it to the substantial and effective practices taken forward in Scotland.”

Scottish Education Secretary Mairi McAllan said any cuts would be “unacceptable”, adding: “Ultimately, we will collaborate on action which we believe can support young people in Scotland but much of what is recommended for England has been being embedded by the Scottish Government for years.

“Fundamentally the UK Government need to grow the UK economy in order to create opportunities for our young people – starting with a full return to the EU and the single market.”

The review proposes replacing the health-related aspect of universal credit and the personal independence payment (Pip) for 16-24-year-olds with a new youth allowance, which would provide every young person a legal entitlement to a route into education, training or work, and a guarantee of support to get the health, employment and functional and practical help they need to get into and stay in work.

Alan Milburn released his review on Tuesday PA Media
Alan Milburn released his review on Tuesday 

The Institute for Fiscal Studies think tank said the plans would mean “many of those with less severe disabilities would be likely to see large income losses initially”, although this could be offset if they entered work.

Scottish Government figures released earlier this month show a slight improvement in the number of young people aged between 16 and 19 years old in education, training or work, with the rate sitting at 93.6%, but the gap between the youngest and oldest in that range at 11.1%.

A report released by PwC last year suggested the rate of Neets in Scotland could be as high as 16%.

Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra welcomed the outcome of the review, saying the level of young people considered to be Neets was a “a moral failing from a political system which has for too long looked the other way”.

“That ends today,” the Scottish Labour leader said.

“While everyone needs time to consider the report in full, the Milburn review proposes a totally new settlement for young people, wherever they live in the UK.

“This includes subsidised jobs and support which ever part of the country they live in, and new legal rights to opportunity and support.”

The Scottish Labour leader welcomed the review PA Media
The Scottish Labour leader welcomed the review 

He added: “This new deal for young people will require new ways of working from their two governments. To move away from the politics of point scoring and finger pointing and towards one that delivers results for people.

“Anything less would be failing a generation of young people who have been ignored by politicians for far too long.”

Reform Scotland finance and economy spokeswoman Angela Ross said the report “concedes radical change is needed” but “avoids answering the big questions”.

“The report proposes state subsidised jobs for young people, paid for by the taxpayer, instead of fixing the economy,” she said.

“Entry-level jobs offering no pathway to a career leave young people no better off because making the state a partial employer is no substitute for permanent jobs created by a growing economy.”

But the Scottish Greens called on the UK Government to reject the review, claiming it was a “charter for state cruelty against young people in poverty”.

The party’s social justice spokeswoman Holly Bruce added: “Labour already allows employers to pay 18 to 20-year-olds less for doing the same work and makes young single parents survive on less because of their age.

“Now it wants to take away support from young people who are sick or disabled too.

“The rent doesn’t get cheaper because you’re under 25. The big shop doesn’t cost less. But Westminster’s cuts mean young parents have less to spend on their children, who ultimately pay the price.

“Cutting health-related benefits will leave more young people struggling to make ends meet, without doing anything to make workplaces more accessible, remove barriers to employment or get people the support they need.”

Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay said the Labour Party has “finally woken up to the failings of a welfare system that is too focused on paying people benefits rather than helping them find work”.

“The answer is to back employers by cutting business rates, invest in apprenticeships and give young people the skills they need to secure decent jobs,” he said.

“We should be reducing the costs facing businesses, not throwing more taxpayers’ money at subsidised schemes.”

STV News is now on WhatsApp

Get all the latest news from around the country

Follow STV News
Follow STV News on WhatsApp

Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

WhatsApp channel QR Code
Last updated Nov 17th, 2026 at 19:23

Today's Top Stories

Popular Videos

Latest in Politics

Trending Now