Not proven verdict and mental health among party pledges

Monday saw party leaders announce a raft of new policies as campaigning continues ahead of May's election.

Pledges: Parties unveil their big ideas ahead of election. ewg3D via Getty Images
Pledges: Parties unveil their big ideas ahead of election.

The SNP have pledged to launch a consultation into the use of the controversial not proven verdict in Scotland, as parties continue to campaign ahead of May’s Holyrood election. 

Justice Secretary Humza Yousaf said his party “is on your side and on the side of our communities” when it comes to criminal justice.

“In recognition of the strong case that has been made for its abolition, we will consult on the removal of the not proven verdict,” Yousaf said in a speech.

“We will work with all parties and with relevant stakeholders to take forward reform of Scotland’s justice system.


“The SNP Government is on your side and on the side of our communities.

“We will use all of our experience to do whatever we can to keep Scotland safe and continue to cut crime and help victims.”

Meanwhile Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar announced plans to boost apprenticeships to ensure Covid-19 does not leave a “lost generation” of young people.

He said the party will place new work opportunities for young Scots at the heart of its jobs recovery plan.


Sarwar said Labour plans to regrow the economy include 5000 apprenticeship places and a sharing scheme so that businesses in key sectors like construction or agriculture take on an apprentice together.

The proposals would involve more than doubling the hourly rate for a 23-year-old apprentice.

Sarwar said: “The most important part of our national recovery is making sure we have a jobs recovery and part of that is making sure we don’t have a lost generation amongst our young people and that’s why we want to create 5000 additional apprenticeships for young people across the country at a higher rate of pay as well, so doubling what the apprentices currently get paid across the country so we can boost the economy, create jobs and make sure we don’t have a lost generation coming through Covid.”

The Scottish Conservatives announced plans for a Nature Bill aimed at reducing the threat of species extinction, expanding green spaces in towns and cities, and protecting marine life.

The bill would also tackle invasive non-native species, increase tree planting, end peat extraction for use in compost, create a third national park and review Marine Protected Areas with a view to expansion.

Party leader Douglas Ross said: “Scotland’s natural environment is beautiful, diverse and precious yet it has suffered from 14 years of SNP neglect.

“The SNP’s own biodiversity indicators reveal a track record of missed emission targets and ‘substantially lacking’ climate change plans. It is tragic that one in nine species in Scotland are at risk.


“Our ambitious and detailed Nature Bill would turn derelict urban sites green for community benefit and in Galloway we would create Scotland’s third national park.

“The climate emergency demands our urgent attention — we cannot afford to waste another five years with a Parliament consumed by the SNP’s separation obsession.”

The Scottish Liberal Democrats have pledged to “refresh Scotland’s mental health strategy” on day one after the election.

The pledge comes as the Scottish Parliament officially recognised there was a mental health crisis in a Holyrood debate brought by the Lib Dems earlier this year.

“For too long, vulnerable people have been subjected to harrowing long waits for mental health treatment. It is impossible to imagine just how hard it must be. Despite the warnings, the pandemic has left a mountain of delays,” said leader Willie Rennie.

“As Scotland begins to reopen, we desperately need to put the recovery first and invest in mental health services. Our NHS staff do an incredible job. People deserve a government that gets behind them and puts mental health at the top of the agenda.

“There is no issue as important to Liberal Democrats as this. On day one after the election, we will refresh the mental health strategy in line with our mental health recovery plan and the £120m we have already secured.

“For people in need or for families in the depth of worry about a loved one, mental health must be taken as seriously as physical health in the next parliament.”

Meanwhile the Alba Party said it will set out its “route to independence” on Tuesday.

In an address scheduled for Tuesday afternoon, leader Alex Salmond will make what he called the “declaration for Scotland”, on the anniversary of the Declaration of Arbroath.

Salmond said: “Tomorrow, on the anniversary of the 1320 Declaration of Arbroath I will set out Alba’s Declaration for Scotland and the clear route to independence – a strategy for immediate action by the Scots Parliament following the achievement of an independence supermajority.

“The momentum in this election is with Alba as people warm to our message that only a list vote for Alba can deliver the independence supermajority that will deliver independence for Scotland.”

Finally the Scottish Greens are calling for fox hunting loopholes to be closed in a bid to put an end to all hunting with dogs “for good”.

Although fox hunting with dogs was banned in Scotland in 2002, an unlimited number of dogs are still allowed to chase foxes from cover so they can be shot.

Candidate Alison Johnstone said: “Most people think fox hunting is already banned in Scotland, but loopholes in the law mean that hunting continues much as it did.

“It is my intention to close these loopholes and end all hunting with dogs for good.”

SNP’s hopes of majority ‘hanging in the balance’ – STV poll

Handful of key 'marginal seats' likely to be the difference between a majority and falling short.

Mark Scates via SNS Group
How will the 129-seat Scottish Parliament shape up after the election?

The SNP’s hopes of winning a Holyrood majority are “hanging in the balance”, according to the final election poll by Ipsos MORI for STV News.

Nicola Sturgeon’s party need at least 65 seats to secure what they believe will be a mandate for a second independence referendum.

While a seat projection – to be treated with caution due to the nature of the electoral system – suggests the SNP could return 68 MSPs, the difference between a potential seven-seat majority and falling short of one is likely to come down to a handful of crucial tightly-contested seats.

And among likely voters, 12% and 14% told pollsters that they could still change their mind before they cast their constituency and regional votes respectively.


Under our calculations based on the new poll, the Scottish Conservatives would remain the biggest opposition party on 27 seats, with Scottish Labour on 19, the Scottish Greens on 11 and the Scottish Liberal Democrats on four.

STV News

With just 2% of the regional vote, former first minister Alex Salmond’s new party Alba would probably fail to win a seat should the poll be replicated at the ballot boxes on Thursday.

Voting takes place across the country between 7am and 10pm, but unlike most elections which see declarations held through the night, the count won’t begin until Friday morning due to the pandemic.

Final results are not expected to be known until Saturday afternoon at the earliest, with some declarations possibly not coming until Sunday.


The poll also saw an even split on Scottish independence, with 50% both for and against leaving the UK.

STV News

Emily Gray, managing director of Ipsos MORI Scotland, said: “Whether there will be a SNP majority or not hangs in the balance.

“The election result may come down to how the parties perform in a small number of key marginal seats, as well as in the regional vote, which is likely to prove particularly important in determining which party is in second place.

“With a relatively high percentage of voters still saying they’ve not definitely decided, all the parties still have something to play for tomorrow.”

Ipsos MORI interviewed a representative sample of 1502 over 16s by telephone between April 30 and May 3.

Constituency vote

STV News

Regional list vote

STV News

Analysis: ‘Poll does nothing to recast narrative’

By Bernard Ponsonby, STV special correspondent

Today’s Ipsos MORI poll for STV News, although showing movement from the corresponding poll of a month ago, doesn’t do anything to recast a narrative about this election that was established well before it was called.


In short, the SNP will win this election, according to our poll, and in all likelihood will win enough seats to win an outright majority. The Tories will hold on to second place, according to our findings, and the Scottish Greens are in for a record haul of seats with Alex Salmond’s Alba Party failing to win anything.

Read more here.

What to expect in a polling station during a pandemic

Covid safety measures mean Scotland's polling places will look a little different on Thursday.

STV News

Polling stations open at 7am on Thursday morning as voters choose the make-up of the next Scottish Parliament.

But they’ll look a little different than usual to ensure safety measures are in place preventing the spread of Covid-19.

Counting will also take longer than normal, with the usual overnight drama replaced by a slow and steady approach possibly lasting until Sunday.

We took an early look inside a polling station in Cupar, Fife, to make sure you know what to expect.

Almost 50 coronavirus cases linked to secondary school

Moray Council said 48 positive cases have been associated with Elgin Academy since April 14.

Moray Council via Website
Elgin Academy: Moray Council said 48 positive cases have been associated with the school since April 14.

Almost 50 coronavirus cases have been linked to a school in Moray, an area where residents have been warned not to let the region “get left behind” as the country continues out of lockdown.

Moray Council said 48 positive cases have been associated with Elgin Academy since April 14.

More than a quarter of the school’s population of around 1000 pupils have since been ordered by public health officials to self-isolate.

The council said the students have been able to access remote learning while in quarantine.


NHS Grampian earlier said it was aware of 46 cases, with no evidence of spread within the school.

Headteacher Kyle Scott has now written to all families with children at the academy.

He said: “I want to thank so many of our amazing pupils for following the rules both in and out of school. 

“I also thank parents/carers for their support throughout; it has been so encouraging to read and receive words of support and I personally thank all those members of our school community for taking the time to do this. 


“It’s by following the rules that we will suppress the virus, and as a school community it is so important that we continue to work together in following the guidance and adhering to these rules.

“If we continue to do these things and remain proactive in our response, I firmly believe that we will beat this virus.

“We are here for you as your school and we want to help in any way that we can.

“We will continue to work hard, liaise with public health as necessary and will do all we can to maintain the safety of our school and prevent any pupils from having to isolate and therefore miss time in school.”

Like other schools in Moray, the building is under an enhanced cleaning schedule, with daytime cleaners who continually clean touchpoints like door handles, toilets and communal areas.

The school is cleaned every night and sanitised ready for the next day, and staff continue to reinforce the importance of mitigations like face coverings and hand hygiene.

Moray Council’s head of education, Vivienne Cross, said: “These have been some of the toughest weeks of the pandemic for our school staff and families.


“We’re reassured by public health that our strong Covid protection measures mean that transmission is not happening within our schools, and ask our residents to make the most of the expansion of testing for mild or extended symptoms, and community testing for those without symptoms, to help stop the spread and further disruption to our children and young people’s learning.”

Scotland is due to move into level two of the Scottish Government’s five-tier Covid alert system on May 17, however Moray now has one of the highest rates of coronavirus in the country.

As reported by STV News last week, the region recently accounted for close to 50% of NHS Grampian’s cases – despite being home to less than 17% of the health board’s population.

Although cases are scattered across the region, Elgin has seen the majority.

As a result, NHS Grampian has expanded its testing and is urging those with symptoms including sore throats, headaches and diarrhoea to book tests immediately, as well as encouraging people to take up asymptomatic testing. 

Ahead of the May Day weekend, Susan Webb, NHS Grampian’s director of public health, said: “We really are on a worrying trajectory in Moray and it is vital everyone ensures they are sticking to the rules to ensure the area isn’t left behind as the rest of the country unlocks. 

“Until now Moray has escaped the worst of the pandemic, but we could now see Moray get left behind as the country unlocks.”

Couple devastated after dog mauled to death outside home

Nurse Lorraine Doherty had taken her Lhsa Apso Jinky out for a walk when he was brutally attacked by another dog.

Lorraine Doherty via Submitted
The tiny nine-year-old pooch suffered awful wounds in the attack which Ms Doherty's partner described as terrifying.

A heartbroken nurse is traumatised after witnessing her pet dog being mauled to death outside her home in North Lanarkshire.

Lorraine Doherty had taken her Lhsa Apso Jinky out for his last walk of the day on Monday, April 26, when a much larger dog jumped on him from behind.

The tiny nine-year-old pooch suffered fatal wounds in the attack which Ms Doherty’s partner described as “terrifying”.

Ms Doherty, a nurse at Glasgow’s Royal Infirmary, had stepped from her doorstep across a car park and on to Coatbridge Road in Glenmavis at around 10pm.

Lorraine Doherty via Submitted
Jinky, 9, was left lifeless following the attack in Glenmavis (Submitted)

Co-owner Julie Wilkinson, also a nurse, told STV News: “They had literally just stepped on to the main street, Jinky was on a lead his happy wee self, and completely out of nowhere this big monster of a dog jumped on the top of him.

“He was torn apart in front of her, it’s just unthinkable.”

The attacking dog, believed by the couple to be a Rhodesian Ridgeback, was finally restrained by neighbours and passers-by, but Jinky was completely limp with his tongue hanging loosely from his mouth.

The pet was rushed to an emergency veterinary clinic. He had suffered massive damage to his spine, his bladder had been punctured and his spleen torn. His owner was only able to be with for minutes before she had to leave to allow the staff to try and save Jinky.

Lorraine Doherty via Submitted
Vets could not save Jinky after the attack (Submitted)

The following morning the vets called the couple to inform them they could not save him.

Ms Doherty had had Jinky since he was born and the pooch had helped her through some tough times including illness. With both nurses working on the frontline during the coronavirus pandemic, coming home to him had proven a real comfort, Ms Doherty’s sister said.

Karen Barre said her sister had been in her bed, struggling to sleep and without any appetite since the incident. Although police were called to the scene immeadiately, they confirmed that they were taking no further action, having referred it to the dog warden.

North Lanarkshire Council said the matter had been investigated and action was being taken.

Ms Barre said: “The only comfort they’ve had over the last year is coming home to this wee dog, he was treated like a wee human.

“Everytime Lorraine closes her eyes, it’s the last vision of her wee dog she sees. You’re trying to prevent anything like this from happening, but I think it will happen again.”

A Police Scotland spokesperson said : “We received a report of a dog attacking another dog at 10.20pm on Monday, April 26, 2021, in Coatbridge Road, Airdirie. Enquiries were carried out and the matter was passed to the dog warden.”


A North Lanarkshire Council spokesperson said: “Our animal welfare officer has investigated this matter and appropriate action is being taken.”

Murder accused said baby son had suffered ‘choking episode’

Brian Penn was quizzed after Kaleb Penn was rushed to Crosshouse Hospital in Kilmarnock, East Ayrshire, in November 2017.

Georgeclerk via IStock
Court: Brian Penn is standing trial over the murder of his son.

A father accused of murdering his baby son told doctors the child had suffered a “choking episode”.

Brian Penn was quizzed after Kaleb Penn was rushed to Crosshouse Hospital in Kilmarnock, East Ayrshire, in November 2017.

Jurors heard how Kaleb, who was almost two months old at the time, had earlier been found to be unresponsive.

The evidence was heard as Penn went on trial on Wednesday at the High Court in Glasgow.


The 30-year-old has been accused of murdering his son at a house in Ayr, South Ayrshire, on November 1, 2017.

Prosecutors claim Penn did “repeatedly inflict blunt force trauma” on the child by “means unknown”.

It is also alleged he did compress and shake Kaleb.

The boy is said to have died at the Royal Hospital for Children in Glasgow two days later.


Penn, of Mossblown, Ayrshire, faces a separate charge of earlier attempting to murder the baby at the same house between October 13 and 31, 2017.

He denies the accusations.

A nurse was the first witness in the trial.

The 64-year-old was working at Crosshouse when Kaleb arrived by ambulance.

The witness told how she had been tasked with looking after the baby’s parents.

Prosecutor Erin Campbell asked her: “While with them, were you present when they were spoken to by doctors?”

She replied: “Yes.”


Ms Campbell then asked: “Were they asked to give an account as to what happened to Kaleb?”

The nurse said it was Penn who spoke, adding: “It was that he had been feeding the baby and there had been a choking episode. 

“He [Kaleb] had vomited, but that it was not vomit.”

The nurse said she heard the child’s dad give that account “quite a few times” to doctors.

Brian McConnachie QC, defending, later asked the witness: “Is it fair to say both parents were upset and tearful?”

She replied: “Yes.”

Mr McConnachie then asked: “From what you seen, there was nothing untoward in their reaction to the situation?”

The nurse responded: “No.”

A paediatric intensive care consultant at the Royal Hospital for Children in Glasgow also gave evidence. 

The 47-year-old claimed he examined Kaleb, who had dilated pupils, and that the soft part of his head “felt full.”

Prosecutor Erin Campbell asked what this meant.

He said: “There may be bleeding or swelling to the brain occurring.”

A CT scan on the baby revealed a significant brain injury, a skull fracture and bleed to the brain.

Miss Caldwell asked: “What was the likely outcome?”

The doctor replied: “He would die and if he survived it would be with a serious brain injury.”

He claimed he asked the parents for a medical history and they “gave the same history from the 999 call for a second time.”

The medic was referred to a statement he gave to police.

In it, the doctor stated: “I asked if he had any bumps on his head as I was trying to establish the cause of the bleed to the skull.

“At that point Brian told me three weeks ago Kaleb had fell on a changing mat but seemed fine.

“He said there was a lump on his head but he didn’t say exactly if they had sought medical help.”

Miss Caldwell asked if that would explain the level of injury on the CT scan, but the doctor replied: “No.”

Mr McConnachie asked if the skull fracture was recent or something old.”

The doctor replied: “I can’t age a skull fracture.”

The trial, before judge Lord Weir, continues.

Emma Faulds: Police dog ‘gave positive indication in car search’

Prosecutors allege Ross Willox killed the 39-year-old youth worker at Fairfield Park in Monkton, Ayrshire, in 2019.

Police Scotland
Murder trial: Emma Faulds was found dead in June 2019.

A police dog trained in the scent of dead bodies gave a “positive indication” during the search of a car in the missing Emma Faulds investigation, a court has heard.

PC Neil Gunderson was giving evidence at the trial of Ross Willox, 41, who denies murdering the 39-year-old youth worker at his home in Fairfield Park, Monkton, Ayrshire, on April 28, 2019.

Jurors heard how a Jaguar car was examined by PC Gunderson and his dog Max on May 8, 2019.

PC Gunderson said Max specialised in “victim recovery” and had previously helped find a body near an area of water in South Queensferry.


He recalled how they had been asked to check a number of vehicles weeks after Willox allegedly murdered Ms Faulds.

The trial was shown the footage of Max searching the Jaguar car. 

PC Gunderson – based at Fettes station in Edinburgh –  told prosecutor Paul Kearney it appeared Max had “heightened interest” in the vehicle.

The officer added: “He is very aware…that there is something there that he would like to get closer to.”


Later in the footage, the dog appears to repeatedly bark at the boot area of the Jaguar.

PC Gunderson said to him it was “clear” Max was giving “an indication”.

Mr Kearney went on to ask: “Do you have any doubt of it being a positive indication from your dog in what he is trained to find?”

PC Gunderson: “I have no doubt whatsoever.”

Willox denies the accusations.

The trial, before judge Lord Mulholland, continues.

Pensioner injured after teen on bike snatches handbag

The 70-year-old fell to the ground after the boy stole her bag on Tuesday evening in Glasgow.

Mrdoomits via IStock
Injured: Pensioner sustains minor injuries after bag stolen.

A pensioner has been injured after her handbag was snatched by a teenager on a bike in Glasgow.

The 70-year-old was walking along Battlefield Road in the city at around 9.45pm on Tuesday when she was passed by a teenage boy on a bike.  

The male, thought to be around 16 to 18-years-old, snatched her bag, causing her to fall to the ground.

Police Constable Jamie Whitton of CID in Glasgow said: “The victim sustained minor injuries as a result of this incident and is extremely upset. 


“The suspect is described as being about 16 to 18 years old around 5ft 6ins in height, tanned skinned, with dark hair. He was wearing a light coloured baseball cap and a light coloured tracksuit left in the direction of Battlefield Road towards Prospecthill Road.

“We are reviewing CCTV and carrying out door to door enquiries but would like to speak to anyone who may have been in the area.  

“I would appeal to motorists and cyclists who may have dashcam or CCTV footage and captured the incident to please get in touch.

“Anyone who has information that will assist this investigation to contact us through 101 quoting reference number 3529 of Tuesday, May 4 2021.  


“Alternatively Crimestoppers can be contacted on 0800 555 111, where anonymity can be maintained.”

Leaked report shows dozens of council venues at risk of closure

South Lanarkshire libraries, community halls and golf clubs appear on a list of possible closures.

© Google Maps 2020
South Lanarkshire Council officials have identified 29 'red venues' which they have suggested could be closed or transferred to the community to run.

Up to 50 South Lanarkshire Leisure and Culture (SLLC) venues could close following a review of the leisure trust.

A leaked draft report has revealed the facilities that could face the axe if the cross-party working group on leisure and culture agrees to take them forward.

South Lanarkshire Council officials have identified 29 ‘red venues’ which they have suggested could be closed or transferred to the community to run.

These include libraries in Bothwell, Burnbank, Halfway, Hillhouse and Lesmahagow and golf courses at Biggar, Langlands and Strathclyde Park.


A number of community halls, including five in Clydesdale, are on the red list while leisure centres in Lesmahagow, East Kilbride, Uddingston and Harelesshill could also be at risk.

Abington, Carstairs, Tarbrax, Red Deer and Murray bowling Clubs have also been included on the red list.

A further 21 ‘amber venues’ have also been identified. It is not currently suggested that these would be at risk of closing but that may change depending on the results of the leisure and culture review and the sustainability of the facilities.

These include nine community halls in Clydesdale, three in East Kilbride and Avondale, five in the Hamilton area and two in Rutherglen and Cambuslang.


Coalburn Leisure Centre, the Jock Stein Centre and Stonelaw Dual Use are also on the amber list.

No formal recommendations have been made yet and the cross-party working group on leisure and culture are currently reviewing service provision and what venues will be needed going forward.

Michael McGlynn, executive director for community and enterprise resources, said: “It is untrue to suggest that the venues in the list have been recommended for closure or transfer.

“The cross-party working group (CPWG) was set up to look at how future provision of leisure and culture services in South Lanarkshire might best meet the needs of local communities.

“As part of this, the focus has been on what leisure and cultural outcomes the council request of SLLC. This has also been the subject of extensive consultation with the public and users groups. The use of all local facilities, how much subsidy is required per user and the availability of alternative provision for local residents to use have all been considered to assist this work. However it would be premature to make any recommendations on the use of any facility before the group completes its work.

“It will be for the CPWG to consider how it wishes to proceed with this information, and if any venues might be better utilised in other ways. Any recommendations that emerge from the CPWG would then be presented to the executive committee/council and the SLLC board for consideration.”

SLLC venues on the red and amber lists

Venues marked with an asterix are on the amber list and would be retained subject to “outcomes from other service reviews and future considerations [regarding] ongoing sustainability and shared outcome delivery”.



  • Abington Bowling Club
  • Abington Hall
  • Auchenheath Hall
  • Biggar Golf Course
  • Braehead Hall*
  • Brocketsbrae Hall*
  • Carmichael Hall*
  • Carstairs Bowling Club
  • Carstairs Junction Hall*
  • Coalburn Leisure Centre*
  • Coulter Hall*
  • Dolphinton Hall
  • Elsrickle Hall
  • Lesmahagow Library
  • Nemphlar Hall*
  • Pettinain Hall*
  • Roberton Hall*
  • Symington Hall*
  • Tarbrax Bowling Club
  • Thankerton Hall

East Kilbride and Avondale

  • Ballerup Hall*
  • Chapelton Hall*
  • Duncanrig Dual Use
  • Glassford Hall
  • Kirktonholme Hall*
  • Langlands Golf Course
  • Murray Bowling Club
  • Red Deer Bowling Club
  • Stewartfield Community Centre
  • Westwood Hall

Hamilton area

  • Bothwell Community Centre*
  • Bothwell Library
  • Burnbank Library
  • David Milne Centre*
  • Eddlewood Public Hall*
  • Ferniegair Hall*
  • Hareleeshill Sports Barn
  • High Blantyre Hall
  • Hillhouse Library
  • Jock Stein Centre
  • Larkfield Neighbourhood Hall*
  • Low Waters Hall
  • Springwells Hall
  • Strathclyde Park Golf Course
  • Uddingston Dual Use

Rutherglen and Cambuslang

  • Halfway Library
  • Spittal Community Centre*
  • Stonelaw Dual Use*
  • Toll Pitch Community Centre*
  • Westburn Community Hall

Story by local democracy reporter Stephen Bark

Man accused of actor’s murder acquitted of 13 other charges

Bradley Welsh was fatally shot at his flat in the west end of Edinburgh in 2019.

Ross Parker via SNS Group
Murdered: Bradley Welsh was fatally shot in 2019.

A man accused of murdering a Trainspotting T2 actor has been acquitted of 13 other charges.

Bradley Welsh, 48, was fatally shot at his flat in the west end of Edinburgh on April 17, 2019.

Sean Orman, 30, pleaded not guilty to all 15 charges against him, including murder, attempted murder, firearms and drugs offences, and is on trial at the High Court in Edinburgh.

The Crown removed 13 of the charges from the indictment on Wednesday, including assault, drug and driving offences.


Judge Lord Beckett told him he had been acquitted of these allegations.

Orman remains charged with murdering Mr Welsh and the assault and attempted murder of David McMillan in March 2019.

Giving evidence on Wednesday, Orman claimed to have never heard of Mr McMillan until the trial got under way.

The 30-year-old denied being at a property in Pitcairn Grove, Edinburgh, on March 13, 2019 when the attempted murder was said to have taken place. He said he could not recall where he was.


Orman said: “I can’t remember, I have no reason to remember.”

He claimed to have got involved with being paid to move stolen cars by a man he had met in prison, known as Omar, after his release in February 2019.

Orman had received a five-year jail term for assault and robbery at a bookmakers, the court has heard.

The trial before judge Lord Beckett continues.

You're up to date

You've read today's top stories. Where would you like to go next?