Personal Independence Payments in need of 'radical reform'

Angela Constance said a devolved benefit system would be based on "dignity and respect".

Payments: Angela Constance believes the current system is flawed. <strong>PA</strong>
Payments: Angela Constance believes the current system is flawed. PA

Scotland’s social security secretary has called for “radical” reform of the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) system across the UK.

Angela Constance highlighted figures showing 65% of disabled people who dispute their PIP award are successful.

The Scottish Government is currently consulting on a Scottish social security system with new powers, including over PIP, due to be devolved to Holyrood.

Ms Constance described the current set up as a “deeply flawed” system which lacks consistency and is failing to treat people with dignity and respect.


She was responding to the UK Government’s second independent review of how the assessment for PIP is working, led by Paul Gray, chair of the Social Security Advisory Committee.

Ms Constance said: “It is absolutely staggering that 65% of people who dispute their PIP award are successful in their appeal of that decision.

“Not only does that highlight a deeply flawed system, but it shows very clearly the number of people subjected to a highly stressful, often prolonged, process to get the support they need and are entitled to.

“It completely fails to treat people with the dignity and respect that, not only do they deserve, but they should have a right to expect from a system that was set up to help them.”


She added: “We will reform the assessment procedures to ensure they work for service users and are committed to working with disabled people through the consultation and beyond, to get this right.

“In the meantime, I hope that this second review will take on board the points we raise – although more importantly the views of the many disabled people who have also responded directly and indirectly to this review – and radically reform PIP to make it fit for purpose and ensure it provides the help it should do to the people who need it most.”

A spokeswoman for the Department for Work and Pensions said: “We introduced Personal Independence Payment to replace the outdated disability living allowance.

“PIP is a better benefit which is tailored to suit each individual’s needs.

“We want to ensure people get the support they need and the independent review is part of our commitment to make sure the system is working as we intended.”

You're up to date

You've read today's top stories. Where would you like to go next?