Surgeon calls for corporate homicide probe over avoidable deaths at NHS Grampian

Dr Mohammed Habib claims that multiple patients died in the operating theatre or following surgery from avoidable deaths

Surgeon calls for corporate homicide probe over avoidable deaths at NHS GrampianSTV News
Key Points
  • Bombshell claims from practising surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary
  • Claims 19 deaths were ruled avoidable in a ‘slaughterhouse’ operating theatre
  • NHS Grampian leadership put ‘careers over patient lives’, claims whistleblower
  • Concerns were repeatedly ignored over several years
  • Doctor describes ‘industrial-scale cover-up’ of avoidable deaths

A consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has claimed dozens of avoidable deaths took place at the “slaughterhouse” hospital despite repeated concerns.

Dr Mohammed Habib, a practising consultant surgeon at the hospital, said he first raised concerns a decade ago, including with Scottish Government ministers and the police.

Following his repeated complaints and internal whistleblowing, a review was instructed in 2022 by Healthcare Improvement Scotland, which found that in 45 cases, there were 20 deaths, 19 of which were ruled as “avoidable”.

The review also found an alleged “catastrophic failure to act while the Grampian leadership was busy burying evidence behind complex medical jargon”.

The allegations come just a week after another Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) review into NHS Grampian identified “serious patient safety” concerns across the health board.

It highlighted that paediatric operations at the hospital were continuing even though the health board had ordered them to stop because of concerns around patient safety.

STV News later revealed that 18 children were operated on at Dr Gray’s hospital in Elgin after the health board had ordered them to be suspended.

Dr Izhar Khan, who is a senior clinician at NHS Grampian, and Dr Khan, a kidney specialist at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, told STV News that management at the health board are “working in silos” and failing to listen to clinicians.

Health secretary Angela Constance described the findings of the HIS report as “extremely serious” and warned that it must be a turning point for NHS Grampian.

‘Sky-high mortality rate’

Dr Habib said in a press conference on Thursday that he began to raise concerns in 2016, exposing a “sky-high mortality rate” at ARI which he claimed was between 15-20% year on year – up to nine times the national average.

The expected mortality rates for HPB surgery are around 2%, and for major surgery up to 5%, the doctor said.

The HPB and General Surgery Service at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI) has operated on thousands of patients since 2010.

A statement read by Aamer Anwar on behalf of Dr Habib read: “Catastrophically, the theatre he operated in could be described at times as a slaughterhouse, which killed through incompetence and negligence whilst not giving a damn about accountability.

“The health secretary’s statement merely scratches the surface of an industrial-scale cover-up at NHS Grampian. The measures announced fail to deal with a deep-rooted culture of denial, arrogance and incompetence.

Dr Mohammed HabibSTV News
Dr Mohammed Habib

“The priority for some senior management appeared to be saving their own careers rather than patient lives.”

“They also failed to explain to bereaved families that their loved ones had died after wrong operations,” the statement continued.

He then wrote several times in 2024 and 2025 to the Scottish Government after becoming “increasingly alarmed” that avoidable deaths were taking place.

Dr Habib wrote to the then first minister, Humza Yousaf, and the health secretary, Michael Matheson, in June 2023, raising concerns.

“I know that today I am putting my career on the line to demand accountability and for the public to know the full extent of this cover-up.”

Dr Mohammed Habib

He was told the Government had “no jurisdiction to investigate whistleblowing cases in individual health boards” and was referred to the Independent National Whistleblowing Officer (INWO) and Police Scotland.

In November 2025, he received a response from the INWO stating that his complaints would not be investigated, describing them as “time-barred” and “outwith their jurisdiction”.

He claims his concerns were repeatedly ignored over several years.

Dr Habib qualified in 1990 and has been a consultant in general surgery & hepatopancreatobiliary (HPB) surgery at ARI since July 2014.

He said on Thursday: “I know that today I am putting my career on the line to demand accountability and for the public to know the full extent of this cover-up. I have tried my very best to use the procedures to go to every institution, but they all failed to act robustly as they should have, failing to investigate or take the appropriate precautions.

“I believe that NHS Grampian should face an investigation for Corporate Homicide, as I believe that the NHS failed in its duty of care to the patients who died.

“There was a gross breach of that duty, falling far below reasonable standards. The various breaches caused or materially contributed to the patients’ deaths.

“Failures by senior management were a substantial element of that breach.”

He claimed he reported 20 cases from 2015 to 2022 of possible culpable homicide to Police Scotland and was told in December 2025 his report was “progressing”.

He says, in his view, the decision-making process at the health board was tantamount to corporate homicide (CH) in the related cases, showing “wicked recklessness and an indifference to patient deaths” as an outcome.

Dr Habib cited two examples of patients who were advised they would be operated on for a certain procedure, but instead they were wrongly operated on for a different matter, and died.

He has claimed their families were not informed of the mistakes.

Dr Habib claims he wrote to the chief executive of NHS Grampian, Laura Skaife Knight, in December 2025.

His statement continued: “NHS Grampian are holding the key to Pandora’s box, and I believe they are deliberately not opening the box. They are avoiding accountability by not being transparent about what damage has been done, while promising heaven and earth going forward.

“In every other death at the hands of the state, families would be entitled to understand the circumstances of their loved ones’ death; we can’t ‘draw a line in the sand’, as Angela Constance has said. Families deserve to know how and why their loved one died.”

Calls for corporate homicide investigation

The whistleblower has called for the Lord Advocate to launch a criminal investigation into NHS Grampian and for an order that no evidence be destroyed.

Dr Habib has also called for a corporate homicide investigation into NHS Grampian over the claims of avoidable deaths.

NHS Grampian and Police Scotland have been contacted for comment on the whistleblower claims.

More to follow…

STV News is now on WhatsApp

Get all the latest news from around the country

Follow STV News
Follow STV News on WhatsApp

Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

WhatsApp channel QR Code
Last updated Nov 19th, 2026 at 12:03

Today's Top Stories

Popular Videos

Latest in North East & Tayside

Trending Now