Major renovation proposed for forest in 'poor condition' in Fife

Major renovations have been proposed for a forest left in “poor condition” in Fife.

The forest could soon see a major renovation if plans from Mr Graham Turton, of Earlsferry, are approved.

Mr Turton has asked the council for permission to remove 19 of the forest’s existing trees at the end of Chapel Green Road and replace them with new species.

“Proposals will create an opportunity to enhance the site’s amenity and biodiversity value for residents and the many visitors to Chapel Green and the coastal path,” planning papers claim.

The Deck House forest garden in Earlsferry sits at the end of Chapel Green Road. The forest and all of its trees are part of the village’s conservation area, and they’re protected from harm.

The 19 semi-mature trees in question were all planted a few years ago after 29 trees from the original sycamore forest were felled.

The new trees are all protected by a tree preservation order – as they sit within the Earlsferry conservation area – but none of them are thriving.

“At least 13 of these displayed moderate to significant crown dieback evidenced by dead leaders and dead buds,” an arboricultural report from arboriculture and urban forestry consultant, Fiona Melville, stated.

“Careful excavation via hand trowel around the base of the majority of trees showed the root collar to be incorrectly located at least 4 to 5 inches below soil level.”

One cherry tree in the north corner has failed completely and is sitting loose in the soil.

Ms Melville continued: “My initial concerns are around the longevity of the existing trees in the landscape, given their current condition exhibited by lack of healthy buds and crown dieback, most likely as a result of planting too deeply”.

The new plans from Mr Turton would see the forest replanted with 24 different tree species, 34 different types of shrub, seven types of climbing roses, and a new hedgerow.

“The new species have been selected to suit the soil, aspect and exposure of the site whilst making the space interesting and beneficial for people and wildlife employing the concepts of a Forest Garden plantings,” the arboricultural report stated.

In general, the new planting plans are meant to better suit local residents and the “many visitors to Chapel Green and the coastal path”.

Ms Melville’s report concluded: “The planting proposal, in my opinion, fully compensates for the removal of nineteen poorly planted trees which are unlikely to reach maturity or expected form.”

She continued: “The selection of new species offers all-year-round interest, good for wildlife and good for visitors to the area and residents alike. The species choices are suitable for the space available and is an excellent starting point which can be developed over the garden’s lifetime.”

The decision now lies with Fife Council planners.