NHS Highland failed to fully assess risks of reducing health visiting service

The report published by the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman concerned changes to a health visiting service for children and families

NHS Highland failed to fully assess risks of reducing health visiting service for children and familiesSTV News

NHS Highland failed to fully assess the risks of reducing health visiting services, following whistleblowing concerns.

The Scottish Public Services Ombudsman (SPSO) published findings of a whistleblowing investigation into changes made by NHS Highland on Wednesday.

The report concerned changes to a health visiting service for children and families, in which guidance was implemented to reduce the expected number of visits due to staffing pressures.

The Scottish Government’s Universal Health Visiting Pathway (UHVP)1 sets out a minimum standard of health visiting support for pre-school children and families.

There are 11 contact visits with children and families under the UHVP which must be carried out by a health visitor.

The investigation found that, when responding to staff shortages, the board did not fully assess the risks of the changes.

It also failed to “recognise and respond fully to those risks” when a member of staff raised whistleblowing concerns.

The SPSO report found a member of staff raised concerns about the potential risks this created for children and families.

Regular contact can help health visitors identify changes in a family’s circumstances or emerging needs at an early stage.

The investigation found that these potential risks had not been “fully considered or addressed”.

The report also found that the Board’s handling of the whistleblowing concerns did not meet the requirements of the National Whistleblowing Standards.

The report makes several recommendations, including asking the board to review its arrangements for making decisions about service changes.

Future decisions should be supported by full consideration of:

  • staffing capacity and service demand;
  • the needs and vulnerabilities of patients and service users;
  • alternative ways of delivering the service;
  • relevant risk assessments; and
  • appropriate governance and monitoring.

Paul McFadden, Scottish Public Services Ombudsman, said: “This investigation found that NHS Highland did not fully consider the potential risks to children and families before changing its health visiting arrangements. It also did not respond fully when a member of staff raised concerns about those risks.

“NHS services face significant pressures and will sometimes need to make operational changes in response to workforce challenges. However, significant changes must be properly assessed and must not come at the expense of patient safety or safeguarding.

“The findings and recommendations in my report have wider relevance for NHS organisations managing workforce pressures and making changes to services.”

NHS Highland has been contacted for comment.

STV News is now on WhatsApp

Get all the latest news from around the country

Follow STV News
Follow STV News on WhatsApp

Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

WhatsApp channel QR Code

Today's Top Stories

Popular Videos

Latest in Highlands & Islands

Trending Now