Couple ordered to cut hedge that they claimed was not a hedge

Professor Angus and Dr Patricia Macdonald said the trees made a 'significant contribution' to the area

East Lothian couple ordered to cut hedge that they claimed was not a hedgeLDRS

A couple from East Lothian have been ordered to trim a high hedge that they claimed was not a hedge.

East Lothian Council issued a high hedge notice to Professor Angus Macdonald and Dr Patricia Macdonald, demanding its size was reduced after their neighbours complained the trees and shrubs were overhanging their property, dropping “tree and berry debris” on it and blocking out the sky.

The couple appealed to Scottish Ministers, insisting the description of the boundary plants was wrong, insisting it was a mix of 17 closely planted trees and shrubs.

However, following a visit to the gardens, the Scottish Government reporter disagreed, pointing out that the definition of a high hedge in Scotland was a row of two or more trees and shrubs that rise to more than two metres above the ground.

Ruling in favour of the council, they said: “I am satisfied that the shrubs and trees are a high hedge, which acts as a barrier to light and prevents the reasonable enjoyment of the neighbouring property.”

The council issued the High Hedge notice ordering it to be cut to and maintained at a maximum height of 2.5 metres, however they excluded an ash and willow tree at either end of the boundary wall from any work, saying they did not need to be trimmed.

In their appeal, the Macdonalds said the trees and ivy made a “significant contribution” to the visual amenity of Ashgrove, where their property sits within the Musselburgh Conservation Area.

They said: “Our relatively small area of garden ground, with its structure of trees and shrubs, not only provides shelter from extreme weather, cleans the air of pollutants, and helps to mitigate high temperatures during heatwaves like that of this summer of 2026, but has also provided considerable support for wildlife of every kind, including more than 50 species of birds, more than ten species of butterflies, and numerous species of bees and other useful insect pollinators.”

The reporter said they were satisfied the hedge would continue to contribute while maintained at the lower height.

They ordered that the time given to comply with the high hedge notice be extended to ensure compliance could be met outside bird nesting season.

STV News is now on WhatsApp

Get all the latest news from around the country

Follow STV News
Follow STV News on WhatsApp

Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

WhatsApp channel QR Code
Posted in

Today's Top Stories

Popular Videos

Latest in Edinburgh & East

Trending Now