News

You're not signed in
Sign in
Sign up

Debate over housing estate portrayal on 'The Scheme'

A new documentary series has been blasted for giving a 'misleading impression' of life in one Ayrshire community.

19 May 2010 15:31 GMT

178444
Debate over housing estate portrayal on 'The Scheme'

Willie Coffey MSP: The Onthank boy says his neighbours there were kind and generous people.

A new documentary series, branded Scotland's Shameless, has sparked debate over its portrayal of life on Scotland's housing estates.
 
The Scheme, which aired for the first time on the BBC on Tuesday, documents life on Onthank, an Ayrshire housing estate. The series producers gained intimate access to six families living on the estate with the aim of capturing the highs and lows of life there over the course of four episodes.
 
However, following the screening of an unarguably bleak first episode, local officials have expressed concern over how the estate's reputation will be affected. A large scale regeneration effort is under way in the area and MSPs insist that while there are problems, it would be wrong to portray Onthank's residents as a group living entirely on the edge.

The first episode of the series focussed on three households. They included a single mum who regularly opens her doors to those with nowhere to go, and a reformed heroin addict, Marvin Baird, who revealed he was desperate to stay on the straight and narrow and start a family with his former girlfriend, who had been released from prison and was trying to kick her drug habit using methadone treatment.
 
The third group were the Cunninghams, a well-known family with more than 30 members living on the estate.
 
The Scheme's makers focussed on one household, headed up by reformed alcoholic, Gordon, and and his partner, Annie. In his younger days, Gordon had been in and out of prison, leaving Annie to raise their five children. Now, with three of their children now out of the family home, the programme followed Gordon and Annie's efforts to prevent their children from repeating their mistakes.
 
Younger son Chris, who described his life as being about hanging around, drinking and taking drugs, insisted: "There's nothing else to do except go out and get wrecked. That's about it." His family were later seen discussing a threat to the 20-year-old from a drug dealer, apparently owed £400 for cocaine.
 
In another scene, a worried Gordon and Annie went to Kilmarnock Sheriff Court to watch their elder son, Bryan, admit to a racially aggravated breach of the peace.
 
He admits he got drunk, took a valium, and caused a racially motivated disturbance in a post office, however, his family believes the shopkeeper has lied about Bryan's actions.
 
After Bryan is jailed for eight months, a sobbing Annie tells the cameras: "He got eight month. They gave him 12 months and reduced it to eight because he pleaded guilty. I thought he was going to let him out, you know. The lawyer spoke great for him. But he says there comes a time... and cause it's racial."
 
An equally distressed Gordon adds: "He gave him the whack for it. He gave him the full whack. Four month off cause he plead guilty straight away. He'll do four out of it."
 
The programme makers say that later episodes will focus more on the efforts to regenerate Onthank.
 
However, some local residents have expressed concern that the programme will lead to everyone being portrayed as living a bleak, breadline existence.

Local MSP Willie Coffey blasted the programme for a lack of balance. He told STV News: "The danger with programmes like this is that they give a misleading impression of an entire community. Featuring the chaotic lifestyles of one or two families might make for interesting TV but it does nothing to support the positive regeneration that has been going on in this community for the past few years.

"Local people are angry about this and how our community is being painted by these film makers.

"As an Onthank boy myself I know from experience how warm the local people are here. When my family suffered two tragic losses in a matter of a few weeks only four years ago, they were first in line to offer help and encouragement and show their support. I will never forget that and it's an honour for me to represent Onthank in the Scottish Parliament and on the local Council."
 
Newly elected local MP, Cathy Jamieson, has also insisted that while there are problems in the area, it has a strong community spirit and a lot of hard-working families.

Mr Coffey added: "I certainly hope to see some improvement and balance in the story lines that truly reflect the generosity and spirit of the people of Onthank."
 

Ads by Google

Share

There are 5 comments

You need to be logged in to comment.

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

  1. Default avatar

    1. 22 May 2010 18:43rondo67 said

    i thought the programme was brill although i think every time a scottish true life programme gets aired they pik the scummest folk to be involved, i also live in an area not so disimaler but have alot og great folk and have a great history amongst all of them but i can also put my hands up and say there are folk like the ones in the area the programmes about

    Report as unsuitable

  2. Default avatar

    2. 26 May 2010 00:05rondo67 said

    shocking that a programme is started to be shown and then scrubbed for legal reasons codswallopp they wid have known b4 it was aired yet again wen the folk of this country see in black and white or even colour the reality of some folks lifes they get upset it may not protray all folk but the majority of this country are living or no someone living like this get a grip and show it wots and all or you wid have wasted the money making it

    Report as unsuitable

  3. Default avatar

    3. 26 May 2010 18:27MrsFesty said

    The people from the scheme were asked if the wanted to participate in the programme - how can they complain if the choose not to be in the show???

    Report as unsuitable

  4. Default avatar

    4. 05 Jul 2010 00:10GED said

    This was a real program,showing the way life really is for some poor,( not scummest ) not lowlife but poor people struggling with drink and drug problems.Poor places in Scotland are like this,poor health also.One of the reasons for this is things like,kebab shops and off sales selling drink and low quality food. See if you can find poor people like this in Newton mearons

    Report as unsuitable

  5. Default avatar

    5. 05 Jul 2010 00:27GED said

    This was a real program,showing the way life really is for some poor,( not scummest ) not lowlife but poor people struggling with drink and drug problems.Poor places in Scotland are like this,poor health also.One of the reasons for this is things like,kebab shops and off sales selling drink and low quality food. See if you can find poor people like this in Newton mearns or Bearsden,I come from a place with some of the same kind of people,and some of the same problems,it doesn't mean they are bad. There are a lot of great people in this program,trying to make a difference.If these people were given help funding they could live happy

    Report as unsuitable

You need to be logged in to comment.

sign in

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

Posts are not actively monitored by STV. The views expressed are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of STV.

Watch now

Video