Following Cardinal O'Brien's admission on Sunday that his sexual conduct "had fallen beneath the standards" expected of him, Archbishop Tartaglia told a congregation that the scandal has "dealt a serious blow" to "the credibility and moral authority of the Catholic Church in Scotland".
The cardinal is to face a Vatican inquiry once a new Pope is selected after saying that he would not contest the claims of three priests and a former priest of inappropriate behaviour dating back to the 1980s.
The revelation has shocked the Roman Catholic community in Scotland.
Cultural adviser to the Vatican Professor John Haldane, Scotsman journalist Peter MacMahon, Patrick Harvie MSP and Catherine Deveney — the journalist who broke the story of the allegations against Cardinal O'Brien — joined Scotland Tonight to discuss the issues.
More About Scotland Tonight
- Commonwealth gold medal boxer on why he is turning professional
- Alex Salmond resigns as First Minister in statement to Holyrood
- Almost a third of Scottish children have been bullied, says survey
- Gordon Strachan has tough decisions to make for intense England clash
- Scotland Tonight: Alan Cumming talks about his childhood memoir
- Education review could lead to children starting school at six
- Royal Bank of Scotland fined nearly £400m over currency failings