News

You're not signed in
Sign in
Sign up

Taxpayers 'should not fund Pope visit'

Leader of Catholic Church to arrive in Scotland on September 16.

04 September 2010 10:53 GMT

195681
Taxpayers 'should not fund Pope visit'

Pope Benedict: Visit likely to cost the taxpayer millions. Pic: © Rob and Lisa Meehan

Three in four people believe the taxpayer should not have to foot the bill for the Pope's forthcoming visit to Scotland, according to a survey.

An online poll of 2005 adults found that 77% said taxes should not contribute to the cost of the visit, by Pope Benedict XVI.

The Pope is arriving in Scotland on September 16, flying in to Edinburgh Airport.

He will then go to Holyrood to be greeted by the Queen and travel along Princes Street, before going to Glasgow, taking Mass at Bellahouston Park.

The visit then moves south of the border.

The findings were issued by Theos, the public theology think tank. The Papal visit to Britain is the first since Pope John Paul II's 1982 trip.

The survey, conducted in August, also found widespread apathy in Britain towards 83-year-old Pope Benedict's arrival - 79% said they had "no personal interest" in his visit.

It was announced earlier this year that the cost of the trip to the public purse could be as high as £12m - not including the cost of policing the visit. The Catholic Church is expected to contribute up to £10m towards the costs.

Paul Wolley, director of Theos, said: "The British public clearly has a problem with the funding of the papal visit, although this could be because they are unaware that in addition to being a religious leader Pope Benedict is also a head of state."

He said only a relatively small proportion of people were actively opposed to the visit and the public was disengaged rather than hostile.

Eileen Cole, of the group Catholic Voices, said the Pope had been invited by the Queen and her Government to speak to the public, not just Catholics, because he has some "very clear, pertinent and wise" messages for society.

"The poll results show that people want to hear what he has to say, and I would add I think it will be worth every penny," she said.

A UK Government spokesman said: "The Holy See is an internationally recognised nation with significant influence across the world, while the Catholic Church has a billion adherents.

"The Pope is visiting at the invitation of the Queen. It is right and proper that the British Government should pay a share of the costs of the visit."

Ads by Google

Share

There are 13 comments

You need to be logged in to comment.

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

  1. Default avatar

    1. 04 Sep 2010 13:53joe doherty dumbarton said

    Why the need for a survey of this kind. He is a head of state invited by the Queen unlike the likes of Pinochet invited by the then non head of state milk snatcher Thatcher

    Report as unsuitable

  2. 2. comment removed

  3. Default avatar

    3. 04 Sep 2010 18:15mick barrhead said

    why all the fuss about public money being spent on a visit that is mostly been funded be the catholic church, it is a state visit afer all. And regards to policing stv's own website published figure's showing that between april 1st 2008 & march 31st 2009 strathclyde police spent £1,714,374 on man hours alone for orange walk parades. As this parade happens every single year and the pope has not visited glasgow in 28 years then if you were to add up the numbers then this visit is merrited.

    Report as unsuitable

  4. Avatar for surfer gran

    4. 04 Sep 2010 18:56surfer gran said

    What a load of meanies! I am not a member of the Roman Catholic Church but I viewed the last visit of a pope to Glasgow and was greatly moved. I look forward to his visit. Surfer Gran

    Report as unsuitable

  5. Avatar for surfer gran

    5. 04 Sep 2010 18:56surfer gran said

    What a load of meanies! I am not a member of the Roman Catholic Church but I viewed the last visit of a pope to Glasgow and was greatly moved. I look forward to his visit. Surfer Gran

    Report as unsuitable

  6. Avatar for surfer gran

    6. 04 Sep 2010 18:56surfer gran said

    What a load of meanies! I am not a member of the Roman Catholic Church but I viewed the last visit of a pope to Glasgow and was greatly moved. I look forward to his visit. Surfer Gran

    Report as unsuitable

  7. Avatar for tab

    7. 04 Sep 2010 19:16tab said

    who pays when other leaders come to scotland, if the taxpayer doesn't pick up the tab for the pope's visit then when others visit scotland the taxpayer shouldn't pay for those either, fairs fair.

    Report as unsuitable

  8. Avatar for tab

    8. 04 Sep 2010 19:18tab said

    well said surfer gran, spot on, it will be good for all people in scotland

    Report as unsuitable

  9. Default avatar

    9. 05 Sep 2010 03:54Opal said

    I feel that it is unfair to expect people to pay for someone who has protected child abusers, helped spread HIV by disallowing the use of condoms and spreads hatred of those who are born bi/homosexual to preach these things in the name of God.

    He is not head of state to me but a man who represents a very rich religion, one that is charging for pilgrim packs and admission.

    This is a PR trip nothing less. A slap in the face for the victims of the Sisters of Nazareth, Blairs college and the others too numerous to mention that have yet to see justice.

    Report as unsuitable

  10. Default avatar

    10. 12 Sep 2010 20:29DavidPun said

    If you research the statistics more closely you'll see that almost every Christian religious denomination in the UK and in the US (I don't know the statistics for the rest) have similar overall rates of child sexual abuse and it tends to reflect the overall levels in the general population with the US being significantly worse than the UK. I'm not sure about the UK, but in the US there is serious worry that there is a huge latent problem with sexual addiction among males, with potentially up to 35% (the latest figures are actually higher but still disputed)being addicted to Internet porn and a staggering 70% of that number repeatedly attempting to access sites that openly portray 18+models as MUCH younger girls. Folks this is not just a problem with the Catholic Church. This is a problem with our society as a whole particularly the male part of the population and the media inspired attacks on the Catholic Church are really just rampant hypocrisy.As far as I'm concerned, if the Pope can convince me that 1) he is genuinely sorry for the Church's part 2) that he is taking steps to eradicate this pervasive social problem from the Church and 3) he can help us accept the moral principles that should make this type of behavior reprehensible, then I'm all for his visit and I will listen to him.

    Report as unsuitable

  11. Default avatar

    11. 12 Sep 2010 20:39DavidPun said

    Regarding HIV and homosexuality. Excuse me, but the homosexual community was almost single handedly responsible for the devastation created by AIDs in the developed world.Condoms and safe sex are simply political strategies by the homosexual community to preserve their hard fought rights to engage freely in sexual relations. I don't blame them for being angry at being condemned by holier than thou Christians, but the HIV issue is simply a medical issue whereby to eliminate a disease we absolutely must eliminate the key vectors by which it spreads. Teaching young people that it is safe to have sex with a person who they know to have a disease that is ostensibly more deadly than smallpox or ebola as long as they cover their penis with a 1mm layer of plastic is just breathtakingly stupid.

    Report as unsuitable

  12. Default avatar

    12. 14 Sep 2010 00:38BEE,BEE said

    i think the tax payer should not pay for the pope,s visit after all he didnt do any thing for the children that was abused by the men of the cloth he covered it up and did nothing for years.

    what about the children that are now adults thay pay there taxes too what about them and there feelings is our goverment rewarding the pope by telling the tax payer to pay for his visit

    The country can.t afford to pay for his visit.

    I would rather pay for the schools and hospital, police,as we need these sevices more

    Report as unsuitable

  13. Default avatar

    13. 16 Sep 2010 15:11Gezzag said

    Only a small portion is being paid for by the government, as they would for any visiting head of state and the Pope is a head of state. Everyone is jumping on only the negative side of things which the pope has stated that the church did not act quickly enough over. What about the good things that the church has done and is doing. If you now reply 'what good things?' then you are just being ignorant as there are plenty of good things and most are not publicised. There have been terrible things done but priests. However, what about the many many very good men and women doing very good things in difficult times. What about the catholic (and christian) population who will gain a lot of comfort and encouragement from this visit. Just wish people would stop jumping on the negative bandwagon, this visit could go a long way to the church admitting its failings and help with reparations being made. Be proud for the nation that it is actually happening. It is a historic event which should be celebrated. There is a time and place for everything.

    Report as unsuitable

You need to be logged in to comment.

sign in

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

Posts are not actively monitored by STV. The views expressed are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of STV.

Online bulletin: Rangers intend to go into administration

 

Watch now

Video