News

You're not signed in
Sign in
Sign up

Is Scientology bad for your mental health?

The Write Factor: As religions go, they don't come much more pie in the sci-fi sky than Scientology, argues David Coyle.

David Coyle

By David Coyle

26 November 2009 20:17 PM

140244
Is Scientology bad for your mental health?

There seems to be new hope for people who suffer mental illness thanks to work carried out by Edinburgh University. Along with American counterparts they claim to have found a gene which may be linked to psychiatric illnesses which may allow new treatments for bipolar disorder and depression.

To me, that’s something well worth investigating. Any attempt to help treat illnesses which are often swept under the carpet or talked about in hushed tones is a good thing.

Well, up to a point. There are some people – let’s call them the Church of Scientology – who think that psychiatry is the root of all mankind’s problems and that psychiatric medicines are a control tool. So they have their own “alternative therapies”. Expensive therapies. Therapies which pull families apart.

If you aren’t sure what Scientology is, and think it’s just a bit of Tom Cruise jumping up and down on Oprah’s couch, in a nut shell, 1950s sci-fi writer L Ron Hubbard decided that to become rich he would invent a “religion” based on evil aliens led by a warlord called Xenu taking over human beings.  He also reckoned that psychiatrists were the crazy ones, and he would charge people to get rid of the pesky alien invaders in their heads through his “religion”, and ultimately save the universe.

Now don’t get me wrong, I love a bit of sci-fi. I’m a huge Star Wars freak. But as much as I think George Lucas could write a cracking story, I didn’t put down “Jedi” as my religion when the last census came round.

Most Scientologists don’t really like talking about the whole “aliens taking over people” thing. It can get a few funny looks down the pub. But mostly it’s because they haven’t paid the hundreds of thousands of pounds required to have these “secrets” revealed to them. By the way, just Google “Xenu” if you’re interested and save a packet.

Tom Cruise knows all about it, and so does John Travolta, but then, they have made a few bob in the movies and can afford this nonsense. And that’s what it is – total nonsense.

Scientology has tried to get a veneer of respectability in recent years. They even had the Metropolitan Police Commissioner speak at the opening of their London HQ a couple of years ago. But more importantly they want to be recognised as a religion, and get the charitable status and tax breaks that go with it.

Every week, loads of people put money in the plate at church, or financially support their synagogue or mosque. But that pays for the roof repairs or the pensioners annual dinner. What does Scientology want to do with the cash?

If Scientologists really thought they could solve all the world’s problems and could be, as Tom Cruise claims, a force for good in the world, why don’t they just do it for free? That seems the charitable thing to do.

It’s getting trickier for Scientologists to fool people any more. In Europe, where Scientology is seen as nothing more than a dangerous cult they’re facing a number of court cases that are going to spill what I can only imagine will be a can of extraterrestrial worms.

In the end Scientology is one of those things where you need to look inside yourself to find out if you really want to take the crackpot beliefs seriously. Go on try it. I doubt you’ll find any of Hubbard’s little green men inside yourself.
 

David Coyle is a finalist in stv.tv's The Write Factor competition. The views expressed are not necessarily those of STV plc. If you would like to read more from this writer, use our comment system below. 
 
 

Last updated: 26 November 2009, 20:29

Share

The links provided allow you to bookmark this page into your favourite social media website. For users with JavaScript disabled copy and paste the URL from the address bar into your chosen social bookmarking site.

There are 27 comments

You need to be logged in to comment.

sign in

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

  1. Default avatar

    1. 26 Nov 2009 23:03stephen67 said

    it's all about the money, I deal with people with mental health isues on a daily basis, any help or breakthrough would be a lessing, in the nicest of ways

    Report as unsuitable

  2. Default avatar

    2. 26 Nov 2009 23:04TinyTim said

    Show me any religion that doesn't ask for money.

    Then i may start to pay attention to it.

    Report as unsuitable

  3. Default avatar

    3. 26 Nov 2009 23:14Dee Ess said

    David,

    There's more chance of me becoming a jedi than a scientologist.

    Gullible nutcases, every one.......although Richard Dawkins would say that about each and every person with religious Faith.

    BTW, think the Swine Flu epidemic is related to us all dying of pneumonia for unauthorised reading about Xenu :-)

    Report as unsuitable

  4. Default avatar

    4. 26 Nov 2009 23:17Dee Ess said

    TT,

    what about football??

    :-)

    Report as unsuitable

  5. Default avatar

    5. 26 Nov 2009 23:18MWD said

    Much prefer Jedi myself.

    Yoda be with you and all that.

    Religion in any form is not my thing.

    Don't need it to be a decent person.

    Never understood the reasons why people need to be controlled by an ultimate being.

    Report as unsuitable

  6. Default avatar

    6. 26 Nov 2009 23:32GL2 said

    David why is it bad to have religious beliefs?

    Report as unsuitable

  7. Default avatar

    7. 26 Nov 2009 23:35Paul67 said

    Never trusted psychiatrists after Basil Fawlty!

    Report as unsuitable

  8. Default avatar

    8. 27 Nov 2009 00:17SFTB said

    David,

    I did look inside my head and, contrary to your assertion, I did see wee green men. 11 of them, in fact. Over the course of the next 90 minutes 3 of their number were replaced by 3 other wee green men who ran about.

    Do I need to see a Scientologist for a cure?

    Report as unsuitable

  9. Default avatar

    9. 27 Nov 2009 08:55Gordon_J said

    Little green men or an old man in the sky?

    What's the difference between a religion and a cult??Seems to me that for most people the one they belong to is a religion and the others are cults.

    Report as unsuitable

  10. Default avatar

    10. 27 Nov 2009 09:24mouldy1967 said

    I had a look in my head one time and realised that there is a wee switch that flips from time to time that wants to make me eat loads of food and or drink loads of diet coke or alcohol

    If I only knew how to fix that then I would be sorted

    As far as religion goes, the more and more I hear about it the more I become dis interested

    Pablo

    Report as unsuitable

  11. Default avatar

    11. 27 Nov 2009 09:38thetagal said

    Look, David. It couldn't be total nonsense or there wouldn't be so many people willing to pay.

    Doing it for "free" is the craziest suggestion ever. How would people delivering the services live while doing it for "free"?

    I'm no fan of the Church but don't throw out the baby with the bathwater. While Scientology doesn't really have a way to handle psychiatric cases or cases where there is organic malfunction, take the average guy on the street and miracles can occur with the technology.

    Not everyone who has received auditing sessions from Scientology jumps on couches. My mommie taught me better than that.

    But when it comes to psychosomatic illness, Scientology can produce outstanding results, and when it comes to freeing the spirit from the burdens of life, it has no match.

    Report as unsuitable

  12. Default avatar

    12. 27 Nov 2009 09:45David Coyle said

    thetagal

    The reason I'm suggesting Scientology does it for free is if they are so convinced they are right and can save humanity from various burdens, peraps even the burden of having to sustain material wealth, why not share it around.

    It's not technology that scientology uses. It's deluded pseudo-scientific mumbo-jumbo invented by a liar to scam people.

    Report as unsuitable

  13. Default avatar

    13. 27 Nov 2009 09:45David Coyle said

    thetagal

    The reason I'm suggesting Scientology does it for free is if they are so convinced they are right and can save humanity from various burdens, peraps even the burden of having to sustain material wealth, why not share it around.

    It's not technology that scientology uses. It's deluded pseudo-scientific mumbo-jumbo invented by a liar to scam people.

    Report as unsuitable

  14. Default avatar

    14. 27 Nov 2009 09:49David Coyle said

    GL2

    I have no problem with people holding religious beliefs. I just think that Scientology is about as far from a religion as you can get.

    Report as unsuitable

  15. Default avatar

    15. 27 Nov 2009 15:30renie said

    Scientology is not all crackpot & does have mant useable workable techniques helpful for survival.

    However the undemocratic methods of control by Scientology are horrific.

    Hubbard stated in 1966:

    "Somebody some day will say 'this is illegal'.

    By then be sure the orgs say what is legal or not."

    L. Ron Hubbard, HCOPL 4 January 1966

    If the above quote would come true another totalatarian regime would oppress the world.

    Already those who run Scientology act as if they own & can do what they please with Scientologists.

    Report as unsuitable

  16. Default avatar

    16. 27 Nov 2009 16:53Jetero said

    The problem seems that David has never talked to anyone that has succeeded in altering their life for the better in Scientology.

    David thinks that Scientology is something it isn't. Scientology is not the church, it is a technology when applied leads to a higher level of survival.

    It is easy to "Think", but it takes work and investigation to "Know" David's opinion reeks of reading 3rd party reports.

    The word Scientology means "To know how to know"

    David is just another case of casting Pearls before swine, sad to say!!

    Report as unsuitable

  17. Default avatar

    17. 27 Nov 2009 19:26giagirl said

    Well Jetero, a lot of people HAVE taken courses, lots of courses in fact, and are saying they witnessed beatings at Scientology's highest levels, coerced abortions, children used as slave labor, blackmail, fraud and every other crime imagineable from this "religion".

    Perhaps you can direct David to some of these people Scientology has "helped". Let's start with Lisa McPherson, "helped" when tied to a bed for 17 days at your Fort Harrison Hotel. Hubbard's "technology" was practiced on her, how did that work out Jetero? How about Elie Perkins, how was she "helped" when her Scientologist son was taken off his medication? Kyle Brennan, how was he "helped" Jetero? Paul Haggis? Jason Beghe? Mike Rinder? Marty Rathbun, Amy Scobee etc etc etc

    Let's talk about what these people "know"

    And David-I love you! Nice work.

    Report as unsuitable

  18. Default avatar

    18. 27 Nov 2009 19:39giagirl said

    How would people "live" if they gave the services for free? How could they live any worse thetagirl? They live 6-8 to a tiny apartment, eat beans 3 times a day, are paid $35 a week for working 80 hours a week, and have no medical or dental care.

    If Scientology really gave a rat's behind about 'saving the planet' they would stop buying up billions of dollars worth of elaborate real estate and people like David Miscavige wouldn't be living the life of a King.

    I always laugh when I hear that tired old "how would people live if it were free" nonsense.

    Of course saving the planet means nothing to your organization's leaders. They're amassing quite the real estate portfolio while the poor suckers who aren't celebrities work like virtual slaves.

    And "I'm no fan of the Church"? Yeah, right. I'm not a Scientologist, but..."

    Good one!

    Report as unsuitable

  19. Default avatar

    19. 27 Nov 2009 21:56David Coyle said

    Jetero

    If Scientology is not a church, why is itself-described as The Church of Scientology?

    Why does it seek civil recognition as a religion?

    Report as unsuitable

  20. Default avatar

    20. 27 Nov 2009 21:58David Coyle said

    Oh and Jetero, the word scientology is made up..

    Report as unsuitable

  21. Default avatar

    21. 28 Nov 2009 00:11John Scott Ridgway said

    Interesting to read how the Scientologists (I call them scamatologists, have infiltrated your message board. They have people scanning the web all day to find articles about them and leave messages; of course, they try to hide behind voices like the one here... who purports to say the scientologists have the 'best way' to get rid of mental pain. If enslaving yourself to a fascist dream of a money making religion by a guy who tried on being Satan for one power kick, then ended up getting pragmatic, and just doing the easy thing -- get some worshipers from the alien addled fifties. People were looking to believe in aliens after all the UFO's started rising to prominence. Whatever was happening during that time, they were able to institutionalize a money making religious formula. A cynical use of our yearnings for a higher meaning that would defiantly set Jesus off in aDESTROY THE MERCHANTS in the TEMPLE kind of mode on a nuclear scale. This article does not touch even the surface on this topic. For further inquiry, hit the rick ross cult institute for a compilation of articles on this destructie, tax exempt in the states (a cynical ploy upon further investigation that involve inventing a psuedo cross, and the Misgivings dude in charge has openly stated he wants Tom Cruise to be the next Jesus Christ. Scary stuff. One has caused enough mischeif in the world for most, and not enough for some. Read these comments knowing half are fake commercials for this scam.

    Report as unsuitable

  22. Default avatar

    22. 28 Nov 2009 04:52MaryMcConnell said

    Scientology IS bad for anyone's mental health. Manipulative, mindaltering pseudoscience has always been bad for humans.

    Report as unsuitable

  23. Default avatar

    23. 28 Nov 2009 20:26Pareidolius said

    $cientology may be bad for your mental health, but it's much worse for your wallet.

    Report as unsuitable

  24. Default avatar

    24. 28 Nov 2009 21:13SFTB said

    Any club that has Tom Cruise in it is one I won't join.

    He played volleyball in Top Gun over a badminton net. Why did he not just use scientology's secret powers to jump higher.

    He was blasted off screen by Jack Nicholson in A Few Good Men. Why did he not use scientology's powers to avoid looking like the duff actor in a school play.

    His accent in Far and Away was Irish via Romania, the click language of the Xhosa and an obscure Inuit dialect from northern Greenland. Why did he not use scientology's powers to hire a decent accent coach or at least drink a Guinness.

    If Tom Cruise ever offers his help to me at a road traffic accident, where he claims scientology training makes him more useful than a doctor, I will batter him so much that he will face the choice between the infirmary and the scientology temple.

    As the poster boy for scientology, he represents well. He is all white teeth and nae brain cells.

    Report as unsuitable

  25. Default avatar

    25. 30 Nov 2009 17:25Jetero said

    Again David misunderstands a simple sentence.

    Scientology is not the Church. The Church is a group of people that use and promote the Scientology technology. Like the Catholic church is a group of people that use and promote the teachings of Jesus.

    All words are made up.

    Good gawd who lets David write for any publication. The guy is incapable of duplicating anything.

    Giagirl knows again only what she has heard from those that have failed in Scientology. Every organization has had failures. But for her to give opinion not directly experienced is a bit silly.

    You all ought to find someone that is succeeding using the Scientology technology and make a friend, believe me you would benefit. Or at least a read a book, you can buy one at B&N or even go to the library if you do not want to support the Church. I have never seen such a lack of understanding in my life.

    Well David and Giagirl prove one of my sayings.

    "Only the stupid don't know they are stupid."

    Report as unsuitable

  26. Default avatar

    26. 01 Dec 2009 17:27lolh54 said

    Well! I freely admit I know nothing about your scientology movement, lower case deliberate. Except as Jetero comments my knowledge is also second hand, but I am old enough to remember many cults that grew up over the years and mostly they expected people to .. give money, time, your life, etc etc, all for the glorification of the leader, who lived in high style or domination of the mind.. and.. if he expects to make converts he really should not be so rude.

    Report as unsuitable

  27. Default avatar

    27. 02 Dec 2009 14:03Jetero said

    lolh54...

    You have to realize you don't know before you can know..

    As for the rudeness read and understand the scientology emotional tone scale..

    http://www.scientologyhandbook.org/...SH4_1.HTM

    Report as unsuitable

You need to be logged in to comment.

sign in

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

Posts are not actively monitored by STV. The views expressed are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of STV.

Related Articles

Poll - Scotland's drinking

How do we solve Scotand's alcohol problem?

Video