News

You're not signed in
Sign in
Sign up

The Cabinet Room: Budget Analysis

Scottish ministers will be patting themselves on the back tonight.

Jamie Livingstone

By Jamie Livingstone

03 February 2010 19:07 GMT

155236
The Cabinet Room: Budget Analysis

Holyrood: MSPs pass Budget as expected

Quite right - passing a Budget as a minority government is no mean feat, just consider last year's wobble.

Tonight's vote went largely as expected - there was no fuss, no drama. 

Ministers started the day with a theoretical majority, come 5pm they turned that into solid votes.

In order to do so the Finance Secretary John Swinney confirmed a series of spending concessions for the Greens and the Independent MSP Margo MacDonald.

But it was the backing of the Tories that proved crucial and they made no spending demands whatsoever.

That may sound strange given the party's previous successes in extracting, for example, more police officers as the price of their support.

The fact they didn't make any similar demand this year shines a light on the changing face of Scottish politics. This time all the Tories wanted was an independent budget review and the publication of all expenditure over £25,000 - they got both.

But why did they aim so low? The answer is, in part, the looming General Election.

A party that's calling for spending cuts at Westminster can hardly demand spending commitments at Holyrood. In short Annabel Goldie's hands were tied.

But this is just the beginning of a new age of thrift.

Whichever party wins the General Election is expected to hold an emergency budget that will transform the existing spending outlook, and not in a good way.

Both the Tories and Labour are eager to cut the gaping UK deficit - albeit to differing timetables.
The consequence of that will be huge pressure on the Scottish budget. So more cuts are coming - that much we know for sure.

This year ministers axed the Glasgow Airport Rail Link to make ends meet. But what about next year?

Major spending cuts - right across the board - are almost inevitable, and that will transform Scottish politics.

Different parties will want different budgets protected but after years of growing budgets - the politics of cuts have arrived.

So tonight Mr Swinney can celebrate - but if this year's budget felt tough, there's much, much worse to come.

MSPs voted 66-45 in favour of the Budget during the Holyrood vote.
 

Ads by Google

Share

There's 1 comment, why not join in the debate?

You need to be logged in to comment.

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

  1. Default avatar

    1. 05 Feb 2010 23:05 345 said

    Jamie,

    Labour had their chance of the Glasgow airport rail link.

    http://www.osamasaeed.org/...-2007.html

    Iain Gray, while transport minister, announced in the Scottish Parliament on 9 October 2002 that GARL, was one of Labours "top priorities" and the plan was for work to begin before 2005.

    A 2003 manifesto commitment from Labour and broken by Labour. Labour were in power till 2007 and they did absolutely nothing to instigate this. Yet they have yelped on and on about it since the SNP have come to power!

    If GARL was such a priority for Labour, why was it not completed already?

    Fact Labour has let Glasgow down!

    Report as unsuitable

Posts are not actively monitored by STV. The views expressed are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of STV.

Watch now

Video